Court Monitor • Dec 9, 2012

A Stunning Loss for the Ambassador Bridge

Text Reader

The Ambassador Bridge connects Detroit to Canada and handles $100 billion in trade every year, amounting to nearly 30% of all the land trade between the United States and our northern neighbor. This is the busiest commercial crossing of any American border. This bridge is a familiar roadway to millions of Americans who vacation in Canada, and many others who travel to Michigan from New England by the straightest route: driving into Canada at Buffalo, and then back into the United States at Detroit. But many would be surprised to learn that, unlike most American bridges, the Ambassador Bridge has always been a for-profit, privately owned bridge. A Michigan resident of Lebanese descent, Manual Moroun, has a billion-dollar fortune primarily based on his family's ownership of this bridge. Congress authorized the construction of this bridge during the entrepreneurship of the "Roaring Twenties" (1920s). But unlike public works projects, the Ambassador Bridge was successfully built and operated through free enterprise, not government control. The City of Detroit tried to impose regulations on the bridge, probably to raise some revenue for the City. But the current owner, the Detroit International Bridge Co., adopted a novel legal argument that the bridge is a "federal instrumentality" that cannot be regulated by state or local government. To the amazement of many, a unanimous decision in 2008 by the Michigan Supreme Court agreed with the bridge owner, and prohibited the City of Detroit from imposing any regulations or zoning requirements on it. Case closed? Nope. Less than a year later, another company (the Commodities Export Company) filed suit alleging that the bridge company had imposed the equivalent of a regulatory taking by closing the only road that provided access to the Commodities Export's property near the bridge. In hindsight, the bridge company should have settled this dispute before the Obama Administration intervened, using the case as a vehicle for challenging the Michigan Supreme Court decision. It's unusual for a federal district court to reverse a state supreme court, but that happened in this case as the federal rejected the theory that the private bridge company was a "federal instrumentality" immune from local regulation. And in an appellate decision written by the otherwise conservative Judge Danny Boggs, he subjected the bridge company to all future regulations and restrictions that the City of Detroit may impose on it. Commodities Export Co. v. Detroit International Bridge Co., 2012 U.S. App. LEXIS 19961 (6th Cir. 2012). The Sixth Circuit based its holding on a finding that "[w]e owe no deference to the Michigan Supreme Court's interpretation of federal common law." While other federally chartered companies, such as the Red Cross, Amtrak, and (in the early 1800s) the Second Bank of the United States, enjoy the status and privileges of "federal instrumentality" that immunize them from local taxation and regulation, the private bridge company is not so fortunate. It can now be burdened like any other for-profit business in Detroit.