President Clinton appointed 12 of the 25 active judges on the Ninth Circuit, President Carter selected three, and Obama picked one, giving Democratic-appointed judges a commanding 16-9 majority there.
Not even the Obama Administration is liberal enough for the Ninth Circuit. A unanimous Ninth Circuit panel consisting of three Clinton-appointed judges struck down a plan by the U.S. Fish & Wildlife Service to delist grizzly bears from the category of "threatened" species. Such delisting would give the government agency greater flexibility in addressing the growing grizzly population that has killed tourists and hikers in the northwest, and required euthanizing or removing 75 grizzly bears in 2010.
Grizzlies are not in short supply in Alaska at all, and their population in the region of Yellowstone Park may never have dwindled if the federal government had not intervened to "protect" them. In the 1960s, grizzlies in the northwest were thriving by feeding on "open-pit garbage dumps," into which tourists would toss food and enjoy viewing them. But government bureaucrats closed these dumps in the early 1970s due to a probably senseless objection to bears becoming attracted to "human foods." The result of cutting off this food source was that grizzlies began dying off at alarming rates.
Nearly 40 years later, the U.S. Fish & Wildlife Service found that grizzlies are doing fine again and no longer need special protection. But the Ninth Circuit overruled the agency and prevented it from doing what it thinks best. Greater Yellowstone Coalition, Inc. v. Servheen, 2011 U.S. App. LEXIS 23332 (9th Cir. Nov. 22, 2011).
The Court based its decision on "climate warming," emphasizing a five-year-old conclusion in a paper previously cited by the agency. That paper asserted in 2006 that "'as long as climate warming continues, whitebark pine as a species and ecosystem is at high risk for loss over much of its geographic distribution' including the Yellowstone area." Id. at 21-22 (quoting Jesse A. Logan, "Climate Change Induced Invasions by Native and Exotic Pests," USFS Rocky Mountain Research Station (2006)).
The Court theorized that global warming could result in an increased population of mountain pine beetles, which could gnaw away at whitebark pine trees and cause their premature deaths. A reduced number of whitebark pine trees in certain areas, according to this theory, might cause increased mortality among grizzly bears. Therefore, the Court held, the Obama Administration should not remove grizzlies from the "threatened" list.
The Obama Administration responded to this argument by pointing out that "poor whitebark pine seed years lead only to a decline in the rate of grizzly population growth, and not a decline in overall population." Id. at 27 (citing a study by Charles C. Schwartz, et al.). But the Court declined to consider that study because the Obama Administration had not included it in its original analysis when it sought to delist the grizzlies from "threatened" status.
The theory of global warming continues to cause havoc in judicial decisions.