For centuries, sovereign immunity has protected government against lawsuits for the harm caused. Its history dates back to English law. If a king recklessly hurt someone,the victim could not sue him for damages.
The same is true for most wrongdoing by government officials today: their victims typically cannot sue for damages, except where government has expressly waived its sovereign immunity. While this makes government wrongdoing unaccountable,it does protect taxpayers against being fleeced by trial attorneys. The deep pocket of government would provide a field day for runaway jury verdicts, at taxpayer expense.
The Vermont Supreme Court recently pierced this sovereign immunity by allowing a lawsuit to proceed against state government for alleged negligence. Kennery v. Vermont, 2011 Vt. 121, No. 2010-448 (Nov. 23, 2011)
As often observed, "hard facts make bad law." Gladys Kennery was an elderly woman who had a doctor's appointment in March 2007. Her daughter, who lived in New York, became concerned when she did not hear back from her mother afterward, so she called the Vermont Department of Public Safety to request a "welfare check" on her. The daughter provided her mom's house number, and allegedly described it as being on the right side of the road from the expected approach, and across the street from her numbered mailbox.
Nearly four hours later, two troopers received the assignment, and the daughter provided the address again to them by telephone. The troopers drove towards the residence, found the numbered mailbox and drove up the adjacent driveway. They knocked on the house door, walked around it and checked the garage, finding no one home. Then they asked a hospital to see if she had been admitted there, and they notified the daughter that her mom was not home.
The daughter next devoted her efforts to seeing if her mom was admitted to a hospital, or perhaps had a car accident.
The following day a postal worker found Gladys, collapsed in her backyard since the night before, where she had been exposed all night to the cold Vermont weather. She subsequently died 12 days later of hypothermia.
Why did the troopers fail to discovery Gladys the night before? They had searched the wrong residence. The troopers searched the house on the same side as the mailbox, when they should have visited the home across the street from the mailbox.
The Vermont Supreme Court found that once government accepts responsibility to do something, then it has a duty to provide the service with reasonable care. This principle of tort law, familiar to first-year law students, is why physicians are often reluctant to help when a stranger collapses in a public place. The physician has no duty to help, but if he does, then he might be sued if the outcome is disappointing. "Good Samaritan" laws have been passed in many states to protect physicians in such circumstances.
But the Vermont Supreme Court found that nothing protects the troopers here, not even sovereign immunity, and they might even be held personally liable if a jury finds that there was gross negligence. Taxpayers would likely foot the bill for this case, and many more that may follow.