Court Monitor • Feb 29, 2012

9-0 Court Tells EEOC To Back Off of Churches

Text Reader

When the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) sued a small grade school affiliated with the Lutheran Church-Missouri Synod, the second largest Lutheran denomination in America, the school fought back. Named "Hosanna-Tabor," this Christ-centered school conferred the title of "Minister of Religion Commissioned," on many of its teachers. When one of those teachers threatened to sue the school in connection with a dispute over her employment, the school fired her, citing her threat to sue as one of its reasons. She then filed a complaint with the EEOC, alleging that she was improperly fired for planning to assert a claim under the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA). In its lawsuit against the school, the EEOC alleged that the school had fired its teacher in retaliation for her threat to file an ADA lawsuit. The teacher intervened in the lawsuit to assert claims against the school for unlawful retaliation under both the ADA and the Michigan Persons with Disabilities Civil Rights Act, Mich. Comp. Laws §37.1602(a) (1979). The demands against the school included reinstatement of the teacher (or, alternatively, future pay), plus back pay, compensatory and punitive damages, attorney's fees, and other injunctive relief. Hosanna-Tabor Evangelical Lutheran Church & School v. EEOC, 2012 U.S. LEXIS 578 (Jan. 11, 2012). This case wound its way to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit, which held against the school. The school then petitioned for review by the U.S. Supreme Court, despite only 1% of such petitions being granted. The U.S. Supreme Court did grant certiorari for review, and then unanimously held against the EEOC and the teacher. Churches and church organizations enjoy a virtually absolute right to fire individuals under the "ministerial exception" to employment laws. Religious employers are protected under the First Amendment from being second-guessed by the court system for their employment decisions about those "who will preach their beliefs, teach their faith, and carry out their mission." Chief Justice Roberts wrote the opinion for the court and, as is his style, he narrowed his holding to the facts of the case: an employment decision about a teacher who held the formal title of "minister." How broadly this ruling applies is not entirely clear, but it is a strong step in the right direction. Justice Thomas wrote a concurrence to expand on who would qualify for this "ministerial exception" to employment laws. He suggested that a church should have the discretion to decide which employees are the equivalent of "ministers" and which ones are not. Justice Alito, in a separate concurrence joined by Justice Kagan, rejected use of the term "minister" and instead said that the title held by the employee "is neither necessary nor sufficient." "What matters in the present case is that Hosanna-Tabor believes that the religious function that [the teacher] performed made it essential that she abide by the doctrine of internal dispute resolution; and the civil courts are in no position to second-guess that assessment," Justice Alito wrote.