Court Monitor • Mar 15, 2012

Court Takes Works Away from the Public

Text Reader

The "public domain" consists of writings, expressions, drawings, music, and anything else creative which may be used and copied freely by the public. Anything created prior to 1923 is in the public domain in the United States and, unless laws other than the Copyright Act apply,these works can be copied by anyone. Works that have existed for hundreds of years, such as Shakespeare's plays or the Federalist Papers, are thereby part of the public domain. Interestingly, it was the lack of copyright protection in Shakespeare's time that probably deterred him from publishing his plays; his work could have then been stolen without payment or credit to him. Foreign works had no copyright protection in the United States prior to 1891. By the Act of March 3, 1891, Congress conferred copyright protection on only foreign works that were printed in the United States, and only if the country of origin extended reciprocal rights to American authors. Even then, copyright protection existed only for foreign works that complied with the requirements of notice, registration and renewal procedures, which are the same requirements that American authors once had to meet. Senator Jonathan Chace sought to make the United States "the Barbary coast of literature" and our people "the buccaneers of books" S. Rep. No. 622, 50th Cong., 1st Sess., p. 2 (1888). But a web of foreign treaties unknown to most Americans has resulted in the removal of some works from the public domain in the United States, under threat of sanctions by the World Trade Organization (WTO). The United States joined the Berne Convention in 1989, which provided for copyright protection of foreign works but lacked a strong enforcement mechanism. Then a lame-duck session of Congress passed the Uruguay Round Agreements Act (URAA) to submit us fully to the World Trade Organization, which has powerful enforcement procedures. The end result of these international agreements is that if someone used a certain foreign work that had been in the public domain, then he might now have to pay the foreigner "reasonable compensation" as determined by a district judge. A variety of Americans sued to challenge this removal from the public domain of materials, which included "Peter and the Wolf" by the Soviet composer Sergei Prokofiev. By a 7-2 margin, the U.S. Supreme Court held against the rights of Americans who had relied on the "public domain" status of these foreign works, and upheld the power of international agreements to withdraw material from the public domain. Golan v. Holder, 2012 U.S. LEXIS 907 (U.S. Jan. 18, 2012). Only Justice Breyer, joined by Justice Alito, dissented. At stake was more than the availability of "Peter and the Wolf." The dissent persuasively pointed out how the Founding Fathers deliberately adopted a utilitarian view of copyright and rejected the approach taken by civil-law nations in Europe. By holding that we must submit and comply with foreign laws for copyright, the Court opens the door to more problems from applying foreign law to America.