Court Monitor • Apr 14, 2012

Are Lies About Military Valor Free Speech?

Text Reader

Is there a constitutional right to speak falsehoods? That simple question has vexed scholars for decades. There is no constitutional right to tell a lie that injures someone else -- that is defamation. But there is a constitutional right to express false opinions about public figures. The Stolen Valor Act, 18 U.S.C. § 704, makes it a crime punishable by six months in jail (or even one year in some cases) for someone to make false claims about having earned military medals. The statute was passed in 2006 and signed into law by President George W. Bush. Two Courts of Appeals, the Ninth and Tenth Circuits, have ruled on its constitutionality. The Ninth Circuit struck down the law as an unconstitutional infringement on free speech. United States v. Alvarez, 617 F.3d 1198 (9th Cir. 2010). Judge Jay Bybee, a possible nominee to the U.S. Supreme Court if a Republican wins the presidency in 2012, dissented and wrote in favor of the constitutionality of the Act. That case is now before the U.S. Supreme Court, with a decision expected by late June 2012. Despite the pendency of this issue before the High Court, the Tenth Circuit recently rendered its own decision. The government had asked the Tenth Circuit to hold off until the Supreme Court ruled, but the defendant asked the Tenth Circuit to decide, and it did -- against him. The Tenth Circuit even cited briefs filed in the U.S. Supreme Court for some of its reasoning. The Court explained, "[d]espite never having served in the armed forces, [defendant] founded the Colorado Veterans Alliance, and he frequently told veterans he graduated from the United States Naval Academy, was a former U.S. Marine Corps Captain, and had been wounded in combat in Iraq. He bragged of receiving a Purple Heart, which is given to soldiers wounded or killed in action, and he boasted that he had been awarded the Silver Star for gallantry in battle. For example, while attending a planning meeting for a luncheon to solicit donations for veterans, Strandlof falsely claimed to have received a Purple Heart. At veterans gatherings, Strandlof used the alias 'Captain Rick Duncan,' and he created online profiles where he claimed to have graduated from the Naval Academy." United States v. Strandlof, 2012 U.S. App. LEXIS 1494 (10th Cir. 2012). When local veterans complained to the FBI, "military officials confirmed Strandlof never attended the Naval Academy or served in the military," and criminal charges under the Stolen Valor Act were brought against Strandlof. The district court tossed out the charges, and the government appealed to the Tenth Circuit. The Tenth Circuit upheld the Act. The Court observed that knowingly false campaign speech about ballot initiatives does not qualify as protected free speech, as recently held by the Eighth Circuit in 281 Care Committee v. Arneson, 638 F.3d 621 (8th Cir. 2011). In fact, the Supreme Court has never invalidated a law against false statements if it includes a requirement that the speaker knew the statement was false. The Tenth Court found that as long as there is adequate "breathing space" between the prohibited false speech and "speech that matters," then the prohibition against lying about military valor is constitutional. The biggest obstacle to upholding the Stolen Valor Act may be Justice Scalia's decision last June declaring violent video games to be fully protected free speech, in Brown v. Entertainment Merchants Ass'n, 131 S. Ct. 2729 (2011). There he ruled, with a one-vote majority, that new categories of speech should not be exempted from First Amendment protection. Lies about military valor, to the extent they represent a new category of speech, will test how broad the First Amendment is.