Court Monitor • Apr 24, 2012

Justices Scalia and Alito Disagree Again

Text Reader

One of the big feuds on the U.S. Supreme Court is not between liberals and conservatives, or between Democrats and Republicans. Rather, it is the sharp disagreement in legal philosophy between Justices Antonin Scalia and Samuel Alito. Casual observers are oblivious to this dispute. Indeed, many liberals predicted, when Alito was nominated to the U.S. Supreme Court, that he would become another Scalia. But while both are conservative, their legal philosophies are very different. Even when they agree on the verdict they bicker extensively about the proper reason, as in the recent case of using the global-positioning-system (GPS) to track a car driven by a criminal suspect. With GPS technology, investigators can secretly attach a transmitter to a suspect's car and thereafter monitor his movements with great precision for many weeks or months. All nine Justices on the U.S. Supreme Court agreed that suspects have Fourth Amendment rights against this type of warrantless surveillance. United States v. Jones, 2012 U.S. LEXIS 1063 (Jan. 23, 2012). But why? Justice Scalia, whose legal philosophy focuses on original meaning to establish brightline rules, insisted that attaching a GPS to a car constituted a "trespass" in violation of the Fourth Amendment. "The text of the Fourth Amendment reflects its close connection to property, since otherwise it would have referred simply to 'the right of the people to be secure against unreasonable searches and seizures'; the phrase 'in their persons, houses, papers, and effects' would have been superfluous," Justice Scalia wrote in his opinion for the court. With this emphasis on the text itself, Justice Scalia is known as a "textualist." In his concurrence, Justice Alito found Justice Scalia's reasoning to be anachronistic and even "unwise": "It strains the language of the Fourth Amendment; it has little if any support in current Fourth Amendment case law; and it is highly artificial. Instead, Justice Alito "would analyze the question presented in this case by asking whether respondent's reasonable expectations of privacy were violated by the long-term monitoring of the movements of the vehicle he drove." Similar tracking can be achieved without attaching anything to a car, as in monitoring signals emitted by cell phones. And today there is no tort of trespass unless there is actual damage to the property; there was none here. Justice Alito's approach, however, would take the Court down a road of shifting lines and judgment calls, rather than the bright-line demarcations of property law that Justice Scalia favors. Justice Scalia picked up three full votes for his position, and Justice Alito likewise garnered three votes for his. Justice Sotomayor broke this 4-4 tie by siding with Justice Scalia's opinion, but adding a separate concurrence to express her caveats and reservations to the reasoning in that opinion. Thus the stand-off between Justices Scalia and Alito in legal philosophy continues.