Court Monitor • May 20, 2012

Supreme Court Rejects "Minority Coalition" Redistricting

Text Reader

A rare victory: a unanimous decision by the U.S. Supreme Court on an issue of enormous political significance. This dispute concerned redistricting for the State of Texas, and the issue of "minority coalition" districts. Every ten years there is a national census, and new congressional districts must be drawn to reflect the shifting and growing population. Texas added four million new residents in the 2010 census, which compelled an extensive redrawing of its congressional and state legislative districts. Texas received four new congressional seats because of its increased population, and those new districts had to be created as existing districts were redrawn. Section 5 of the Voting Rights Act of 1965 requires "preclearance" of Texas's redistricting before elections are held. This preclearance consists ofsubmitting the new maps to a three-judge panel from the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia, which then decides whether the redistricting was for the purpose or effect of "denying or abridging the right to vote on account of race or color." 42 U.S.C. §1973c(a). Elections cannot be held under the old maps, and Supreme Court precedent dictates that elections may not be held under new maps until they have been precleared. The result has been to delay the presidential and legislative primaries in Texas until months after their original date. Opponents of the new district maps did not await a ruling from the court in D.C., but challenged the maps directly in federal court in Texas. There a three-judge federal panel rejected the new maps and redrew the districts. This court-ordered redistricting reportedly would have yielded a net gain of about five additional seats for Democrats compared with the legislature-drawn districts. Texas appealed quickly to the U.S. Supreme Court, which rejected how the lower court redrew the maps. Instead, the Supreme Court held that the lower court should have deferred far more to the legislature-drawn maps than it did. Perry v. Perez, 132 S. Ct. 934, (2012). The most significant part of the Supreme Court's decision, in addition to rejecting judicial activism, was how it expressly repudiated the concept of "minority coalition" districts that was contemplated by the lower court. A 'minority coalition" district combines two different minorities, such as Hispanics and African Americans, in order to make the sum of their populations a majority of the district. Because Hispanics and blacks typically vote for Democrats, the real effect of forming "minority coalition" districts is to expand the number of Democrat majority districts. The Voting Rights Act allows, and even requires, the creation of black-majority districts based on a theory of discrimination against that specific minority group, but it offends the race-blind Constitution for courts to create coalition-majority districts based on the fiction that different minority groups have the same political interests. If judicial activism were allowed to do this, then Democrats could gain numerous seats in Congress based on racial gerrymandering that combines different racial groups for political purposes. The Supreme Court tossed out the judge-drawn maps and closed the door against "minority coalition" redistricting.