Once Republicans swept into power in most state legislatures in 2011, eight states enacted "voter ID" laws to cut down on fraudulent voting. These laws typically require a voter to present a government-issued identification before voting. Since 2003 a total of 21 states have passed some form of voter ID requirement, although many are too weak to be meaningful.
Five of the eight states that passed a voter ID law in 2011 are defending it in court challenges. Most Southern states are subject to the Voting Rights Act, which gives the Department of Justice special powers to object to changes in voting procedures, supposedly to guard against discrimination. In practice, Democrats have long opposed voter ID laws for political reasons independent of any alleged discrimination.
In 2008, the U.S. Supreme Court upheld a photo identification requirement of voters, which had been enacted by Indiana. The Michigan Supreme Court also upheld its photo ID requirement, but the Missouri Supreme Court invalidated a photo ID law enacted there. Even where photo ID is required, as in Indiana, there are typically bypass procedures for voting without identification, as in filing a little extra paperwork.
It took Texas several years to pass its new voter ID law in 2011, which requires presentation of a government-issued identification in order to vote. Democrats bitterly objected to this law and filibustered nearly all legislation in 2009 to block this single bill from passing. When Republicans swept to overwhelming majorities in the Texas legislature in 2010, this bill then passed in 2011.
But the Obama Administration intervened under the guise of the Voting Rights Act, declaring the law to be discriminatory and blocking Texas from enforcing it. Texas subsequently sued in district court in D.C., asking the court to declare Section 5 of the Voting Rights Act unconstitutional. This case is pending before a three-judge panel of district court judges; the NAACP Texas State Conference and the Mexican American Legislative Caucus have participated in this case to oppose Texas's new law.
Three other states subject to the Voting Rights Act have also passed voter ID laws: South Carolina, Alabama and Mississippi. (In addition to Texas, the other states controlled by the Voting Rights Act are Alaska, Arizona, Georgia, Louisiana and Virginia.) The Obama Administration has already blocked South Carolina's law.
The states of Kansas, Tennessee and Rhode Island are not subject to the Voting Rights Act, and thus their voter ID requirements are fully enforceable regardless of opposition by the Obama Administration.
Because these voter ID laws affect upcoming elections, courts may rule on an expedited basis. Some predict that this issue will reach the U.S. Supreme Court, and it may provide the Court with a vehicle for considering the constitutionality of the broad scope of the Voting Rights Act, which in 2006 Congress extended for another 25 years. The Voting Rights Act controls seven states and parts of several others.