Court Monitor • Jun 17, 2012

Judges Surprisingly Hostile to Bible Study Lawsuit

Text Reader

Most federal appellate courts are dominated by Democrat-appointed judges. The Sixth Circuit (presiding over Michigan, Ohio, Kentucky and Tennessee) is one of the exceptions, featuring a 10-6 advantage in Republican-appointed active judges. So, the Alliance Defense Fund had good reason to think it was appealing a Bible study dispute in Tennessee to a receptive court. But a panel with a majority of Republican-appointed judges rendered a strikingly harsh opinion against it. This case began when a public school fourth-grader learned that he could not have a Bible study class during recess. The principal subsequently sent a letter to parents informing them that she had told students and a parent "that children could not have a Bible study class during the school day." Whitson v. Knox County Board of Education, 2012 FED App. 0304N (6th Cir. Mar. 20, 2012). After that, the Superintendent, the President of the School Board, and the principal approved a press release to the media that included this quote by the principal: "I indicated to the students and the parents that I did not feel that an organized activity of this type was appropriate during the school day. . . . While we do not discourage students from reading at recess, I think that a daily planned activity that is stationary or physically static in nature defeats the real purpose of recess. The purpose is to give students an opportunity to have some physical activity during the school day." But according to a local minister who had previously met with the principal about this same issue, her concern then was really about the so-called separation of church and state. Alliance Defense Fund (ADF) filed a federal lawsuit on behalf of the student, alleging violation of his First Amendment rights. This case wound its way to a two-day jury trial over the objection of ADF's request for a bench trial (a trial conducted by a judge without a jury). The jury held against the student, finding no violation of his constitutional rights. ADF appealed on behalf of the student. The Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit agreed that several errors had been committed by the trial court, most notably in how it mistakenly held a jury trial over the objection of the plaintiff. It is surprising that ADF would not expect a jury in eastern Tennessee to be sympathetic to its case, but ADF was subsequently proven right in its strategy. The appellate court, despite recognizing that ADF had a right to a bench trial, declined to overturn the verdict. The appellate decision, written by a judge appointed by President George W. Bush, had unusually harsh words for ADF's pursuit of this case, callings its grounds for appeal "minimal" and implicitly lamenting the "media frenzy" that occurred. The Court declared that "[t]he complaint should not have been filed based on such scant evidentiary support," even though the appellate court admitted that the allegations were supported by evidence that came forth during the case.