Court Monitor • Aug 19, 2012

The Constitutional Right to Record in Public

Text Reader

Nationwide, citizens are using their cell phones to record things in public. But some government officials have taken a dislike to that, and ordinary people have been arrested for recording what they observe on city streets. Big Brother government apparently does not like being scrutinized by the public. The media recently complained to the Department of Justice. The Department of Justice sent an extraordinary letter dated May 14, 2012, declaring that the public has a First Amendment right to video government officials as they discharge their duties. The letter stated: "Recording governmental officers engaged in public duties is a form of speech through which private individuals may gather and disseminate information of public concern, including the conduct of law enforcement officers." Even better, this letter confirms that if a government agent seizes or destroys someone's recordings, then this violates the victim's Fourth Amendment rights unless there was a warrant or court order justifying it. It was the secret filming of the police beating of Rodney King in California that led to a national debate back in 1991, and even riots at one point. Few would argue that it should be illegal for a bystander to record that type of public incident. Yet today there are many reported instances of people being harassed or even arrested merely for recording in public what they see government officials do. The theory behind some of these arrests is that eavesdropping is not permitted unless at least one person subjected to it agrees, and in some states all the subjects of the taping must agree to it before it is considered legal. Videotaping others in public is hardly eavesdropping, yet that is the basis justifying some of these arrests. In other cases, the videotaping is considered to be obstruction of a government duty. In 2011, on Long Island, a freelance photographer was charged with obstruction of governmental administration after the police told him to stop filming them, and he persisted from another location. In another case, a Rochester woman was arrested for videotaping police while standing on her own lawn. Many of these charges are eventually dropped, and last year the Baltimore police department issued a policy guidance instructing its officers that there is a public right to video them in public. But the Department of Justice letter said that Baltimore had still not gone far enough in stressing the importance of this accountability. The letter emphasized the need to "engender public confidence in our police departments, promote public access to information necessary to hold our governmental officers accountable, and ensure public and officer safety" by videotaping. Except in rare circumstances of safety or other legitimate concerns, officers should "not to threaten, intimidate, or otherwise discourage an individual from recording police officer enforcement activities or intentionally block or obstruct cameras or recording devices."