Court Monitor • Sep 11, 2012

$22,500 per Song!

Text Reader

Some rock music today can be dreadful to listen to. But imagine downloading it for "free" only to be socked later with a court penalty of $22,500 per song! Boston University student Joel Tenenbaum was one of the targets of a crackdown led by the Recording Industry Association of America against individuals, often students, who were transferring copyrighted music over the internet without paying for it. RIAA and the music industry sued more than 12,000 people for this. Thousands more received notices but were not actually sued. Over the past 15 years there have been numerous internet sites facilitating the distribution of music for free to the public, to the consternation of RIAA and the music industry that claims to be losing billions of dollars from this. Music file-sharing sites included Napster, which was immensely popular more than a decade ago but was forced by litigation to convert to a fee-based site. Other sites enabling free music distribution were Grokster, Morpheus and Kazaa. Grokster lost a Supreme Court ruling, which ended its method of operation. In 2008, an astounding total of 800 songs were downloaded without copyright permission by the average teenager, according to one study. RIAA and music companies complained that new sites facilitating this activity were constantly arising on the internet. The music industry had sent Joel Tenenbaum a letter complaining about his activities, but he allegedly continued copying music online while blaming houseguests, sisters and burglars for the activity from his location. Lacking a sense of humor, a dizzying array of music companies followed up by suing Tenenbaum. Tenenbaum turned to cerebral firepower at Harvard Law School to help defend his case. But that turned out badly, with a jury imposing a statutory penalty of $22,500 for each of 30 songs that he had copied without permission. The fine totaled $675,000, which the trial judge found to be unconscionably excessive. She dropped a decimal point and made it $67,500, slightly more than the cost of one year's education at a college across the Charles River from Boston University. This reduction in the fine did not sit well with the music industry, which took this on appeal. Tenenbaum's appellate counsel argued that the music industry was engaging in spam-litigation in its endless pursuit of this matter. But the Court of Appeals for the First Circuit held in favor of the music industry, and reinstated the massive verdict. Tenenbaum sought review by the U.S. Supreme Court, hoping it would sing a different tune. But the Obama Administration, which should be grateful for how supportive college students were in electing Obama, filed a brief against Tenenbaum's attempt at Supreme Court review. The leftist music industry and Hollywood contribute millions of dollars to Obama's campaigns, which is probably worth more than all the student activism combined. With the Obama Administration urging against Supreme Court review, the Court declined to hear Tenenbaum's case. Joel Tenenbaum v. Sony BMG Music Entertainment (May 21, 2012). This case next returns to the trial court for possible adjustment of the massive fine by a new judge, now that the prior trial judge has retired.