When Wisconsin Governor Scott Walker won a stunning victory against the public sector unions that tried to recall him earlier this year, many Americans assumed that settled the issue once and for all against unlimited power by government unions. After all, even President Franklin Delano Roosevelt opposed public sector unions. Government workers have the political process to protect their rights, and there is no evidence of exploitation of government workers by politicians. More often than not, elected officials favor government workers over those in the private sector, as President Obama does.
Governor Walker trimmed the ability of government workers to engage in collective bargaining on certain issues like pension benefits. The term "collective bargaining" refers to how workers in a union band together to make demands as a group or else the employer can be subjected to a devastating strike. The Chicago public school teachers' strike was an example of the use of collective bargaining by government workers. When politicians cave in to the demands to avert or end a strike, those extra benefits paid to government workers by virtue of collective bargaining come out of the pockets of taxpayers and the private sector.
In March 2011, Wisconsin Governor Walker signed a law to end collective bargaining by government workers with respect to their pensions and health benefits, resulting in their footing the bill for more of the expenses. This enabled Walker to balance the budget for a state that was running a massive $3 billion budget deficit under the prior Democratic leadership.
But even though the Wisconsin Supreme Court upheld this law, in September a county judge invalidated key parts of it for city, county and school workers as somehow being in violation of rights of equal representation, free speech and freedom of association. Madison Teachers, Inc., et al. v. Walker (Dane County Circuit Court Sept. 14, 2012). The court also held that, under the Wisconsin Constitution, the state could not dictate the rights of employees of the Milwaukee government to decide how to fund their pensions. The state is appealing.
This ruling has interfered with the ability of the state legislature and governor to control spiraling costs in the state. It threw negotiations under the law by workers into disarray again, after several elections had presumably resolved the matter. Meanwhile, a challenge in federal court to the law is also being pursued by its opponents.
Other good laws passed by Republican majorities who swept into the state legislatures in 2010 have been blocked or invalidated by judicial supremacists. Laws invalidated by courts include prolife legislation, rules requiring drug testing for welfare recipients, and attempts to privatize prisons.
But liberal legislation, in contrast, is upheld by the courts, as the ObamaCare decision by the U.S. Supreme Court demonstrated last summer. This asymmetry of conservative legislation being invalidated while liberal legislation is upheld has a doubly negative effect. It is not enough to urge deference to the legislature when so many judges will defer only if the legislation is liberal.
After the decision, critics of Walker complained about how Wisconsin's beloved football team, the Green Bay Packers, lost a game because the NFL did not grant the demands of the striking experienced referees (afterward, amid much publicity, the NFL caved in to the union). But the debate in Wisconsin over Walker and the recall effort was never about private sector unions; it has been about whether government workers should use collective bargaining to force taxpayers to fund their costly benefits.