Football in Texas is a big deal, and not just for the Dallas Cowboys. College home football games by the University of Texas cause a sell-out of hotel space in Austin, and million-dollar stadiums are built even for high school football teams.
At the beginning of high school football games it has been customary for cheerleaders on each side to hold banners with unflattering and even unsavory sayings about the other side, such as calling for them to be crushed in the game. But then some Christian cheerleaders had the brilliant idea to put wholesome Bible verses on the banners to root their team on.
Someone famous who did something similar was Tim Tebow, who won the Heisman Trophy as the top college player while only a sophomore, and led his University of Florida team to an extraordinary two national championships. He would put citations to the Bible, including John 3:16, under his eyes so that the television cameras broadcast them to millions of viewers.
Nobody tried to stop Tebow from doing this, but an out-of-state group did try to stop the Texas public school cheerleaders from putting biblical verses on their banners. Even though the crowd liked the banners, the players liked the banners, and the small town liked the banners, an out-ofstate group cited a complaint by one anonymous person to demand censorship of the Bible verses at the games.
No law prohibits cheerleaders from displaying Bible verses at public school games. But the public high school superintendent decided to please the group seeking the censorship, rather than defend the cheerleaders who were exercising their rights to express their Christian faith.
Texas high school cheerleaders stood up against the attempt to censor them. They sued in state court with the assistance of the Liberty Institute. This case presented the issue of a "heckler's veto": can merely one person in an entire stadium of fans and players censor what everyone else apparently wants to see or hear, because that one person does not like the religious message? The objector is not even required to attend the event.
In a clever legal move, the Liberty Institute sued in a Texas state court, where judges are elected. To the chagrin of opponents of Christianity at public school events, the state court judge issued an injunction against the school, prohibiting it from censoring these banners by the cheerleaders Matthews v. Kountze Independent School District, No. 53526, (356th District Court, Oct. 18, 2012). The injunction is temporary, but it allows use of the Bible verses for the remainder of the football season, until the court fully considers whether to allow the Christian banners permanently.
This decision won national support, and thousands of fans showed their support of the smalltown cheerleaders over the internet.
This case may mark the beginning of the end to the phony separation of church and state theory that has harmed public schools for decades. Freedom of religious speech is popular with young people, and liberal attempts to censor that speech should be rejected.