Court Monitor • Oct 10, 2013

Two Courts Invalidate Obama's Recess Appointments

Text Reader

On January 4, 2012, Obama made three appointments to the National Labor Relations Board. But the appointees were never confirmed by the Senate. Although the legislature had already reconvened for the new year, Obama claimed that he was making recess appointments that did not require Senate confirmation. The NLRB appointments were crucial to the agency's agenda of obstructing private business activity. The NLRB ruled against a New Jersey nursing home and a Washington bottling facility. A majority of the five-seat panel was needed to take these actions. Without Obama's appointments, there would have been three vacancies and no quorum would have existed. The businesses took the NLRB to court, and federal appeals courts invalidated the agency's actions on the grounds that the NLRB members never should have assumed their posts. In Noel Canning v. NLRB, the Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit ruled that Obama's appointments were invalid. The Court held that recess appointments must be made between annual sessions, as opposed to during a break within a single session. The Court observed that "[t]he available evidence shows that no President attempted to make an intrasession recess appointment for 80 years after the Constitution was ratified." The Court held that the lack of intrasession recess appointments in the early years of the Republic " 'suggests an assumed absence of [the] power' to make such appointments." The Court also used a close examination of the text of the Recess Appointments Clause in its invalidation of Obama's appointments. The Constitution refers to "the Recess of the Senate." As the Court noted, "that definite article suggests specificity." If the Constitution were referring to a recess that could be either intrasession or intersession, the Court concluded, it would not have used the definite article. In addition to objecting to the intrasession nature of Obama's recess appointments, the D.C. Circuit also held that, for any recess appointment, the vacancy being filled must also have arisen during the Senate recess. The Constitution's authorization of recess appointments refers only to "Vacancies that may happen during the Recess of the Senate." The Court held that "a vacancy happens . . . only when it first arises," thus invalidating Obama's recess appointments on the additional grounds that the vacancies were not created during the Senate recess. The D.C. Circuit's decision to invalidate Obama's appointments for multiple reasons is a victory for conservative principles. A second victory followed. The Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit, in NLRB v. New Vista Nursing & Rehabilitation, came up with additional reasons to rule that Obama's NLRB appointments were invalid. That court examined the Constitution's stipulation that the terms of recess appointments "shall expire at the End of . . . [the] next Session [of the Senate]." The Court noted that if the Framers had intended to give the President the authority to make recess appointments during intrasession breaks, "we would expect the recessappointment term to last only until the end of that [current] session." The Court concluded that recess appointments are only permitted during intersession recesses. The Supreme Court granted cert. and will hear an appeal of the D.C. Circuit's decision in the fall. Its justices should reaffirm the sound logical arguments and historical analyses set forth by the federal appellate courts.