In two recent cases, the Supreme Court ruled in favor of employers and rejected broad readings of Title VII of the Civil Rights Act. The Court's business-friendly holdings are victories for our nation, as they prevent the payments that employers would have had to make due to contrived applications of the Civil Rights Act.
In one of the cases, Vance v. Ball State University, an African-American Dining Services employee claimed that she had experienced workplace discrimination. She accused a white co-worker of "glaring at her, slamming pots and pans around her, and intimidating her." The plaintiff argued that the employer should be held liable for workplace harassment under Title VII of the Civil Rights Act.
But Title VII does not require the punishment of employers for all types of workplace harassment. If the offending individual is not a supervisor of the victim, but merely a co-worker, and the employer is not negligent in addressing the situation, the employer is not held liable. Punishing the employer in such a situation would only harm the business and would unnecessarily impede free-market activity.
The Court held that supervisors must be more than merely "individuals with the power to assign daily tasks." The Court observed that, in the modern workplace, "members of a team may each" direct "a particular aspect of the [team's] work." In such a situation, it would not make sense to consider each member of the team to be a supervisor of each other member of the team. The Court defined a supervisor to be someone "empowered by the employer to take tangible employment actions against the victim." The Court thus protected employers from unreasonable liability claims by disgruntled employees.
In another case, University of Texas Southwestern Medical Center v. Nassar, the Supreme Court affirmed the limited scope of Title VII's prohibition of retaliative actions by employers. Title VII prohibited employment actions that happened "because" the relevant employee belonged to a particular race, sex, or other protected group.
In 1991, Congress expanded the ban on discrimination against protected classes by requiring only that discrimination be a "motivating factor" for the relevant employment action, instead of being the cause of the action. The 1991 law did not, however, strengthen the ban on retaliation. The Court noted that "[T]he text of the motivating-factor provision . . . proceeds to address only . . . race, color, religion, sex, and national origin." Since "[t]he text . . . says nothing about retaliation claims," the Court held, retaliation claims did not gain additional coverage under the 1991 expansion of the Civil Rights Act.
The Supreme Court correctly identified the limits of lawsuits for employer retaliation. The government should not be able to force employers to waste more money without even passing a law requiring them to do so. Conservatives applaud the Court's protections of the rights of businesses to make their own decisions.