Court Monitor • Oct 27, 2013

Circuits Split on Abortifacient Mandate

Text Reader

Two federal circuit courts have issued conflicting decisions about the right of business owners to follow their religious beliefs by omitting abortifacient coverage from the health insurance they provide to employees. An abortifacient is a pill that induces abortion. In June, the Tenth Circuit U.S. Court of Appeals ruled that the owners of a Christian business can adhere for now to their Christian principles and not be immediately forced to violate them. Hobby Lobby Stores, Inc. v. Sebelius, 2013 U.S. App. LEXIS 13316 (June 27, 2013). The case will return to the trial court for more litigation. Hobby Lobby is a family-run arts and crafts retailer with hundreds of shops throughout the United States. The HHS mandate requires Hobby Lobby to pay for abortifacients for its employees. The company's owners objected, saying that their religious beliefs precluded them from paying for the taking of innocent human life. Many news sources have incorrectly reported that Hobby Lobby objects to contraception; in fact, the key issue was that the owners of Hobby Lobby did not want to help abort pregnancies after conception. If the owners of Hobby Lobby had followed their religious beliefs and refused to pay for abortifacients, the company would have been fined over $1 million per day, and may have been forced out of business. Leftists argue that such a shutdown would be acceptable. They want to restrict religious liberty to a narrow category of churches and nonprofit groups. But the Court held that "[a] religious individual may enter the for-profit realm intending to demonstrateto the marketplace that a corporation can succeed financially while adhering to religious values. As a court, we do not see how we can distinguish this form of evangelism from any other." The Court went on to note that denying religious liberty rights to for-profit organizations takes us down a slippery slope: "What if Congress eliminates the for-profit/non-profit distinction in tax law? Do for profit corporations then gain Free Exercise rights? Or do non-profits lose Free Exercise rights?" The First Amendment's religious freedom guarantee was meant to apply to all. Denying religious liberty to profitable enterprises could lead to the loss of everyone's religious freedom. The Tenth Circuit was right to allow religious business owners to act in accordance with their beliefs. Soon afterward, however, the Third Circuit U.S. Court of Appeals ruled against religious liberty in a similar case, deciding that the religious owners of a Pennsylvania cabinet company had to provide abortifacients for employees. Conestoga Wood Specialties Corp. v. Sebelius, 2013 U.S. App. LEXIS 15238 (July 26, 2013). The court wrote that "a for-profit, secular corporation cannot assert a claim under the Free Exercise Clause" and that "the free exercise claims of a company's owners cannot pass through to the corporation." The Third Circuit majority decided it could unilaterally determine which corporations are worthy of religious liberty rights, and which are not. But as Judge Kent Jordan noted in his dissenting opinion, the Constitution nowhere makes the 'for-profit versus non-profit' distinction invented by the government." The opposing decisions from the Tenth and Third Circuits set the stage for a likely Supreme Court ruling on the issue. When the Supreme Court ultimately hears a case on religious liberty and the HHS mandate, it should stand up for the right to refuse to pay for abortifacients.