Court Monitor • Nov 10, 2013

Send a Text, Be Liable for a Car Crash

Text Reader

A New Jersey appellate court held that a person who knowingly sends a text message to a driver likely to read it can be held liable for an accident caused by the distracted driver. The lawsuit was brought by the Kuberts, a man and woman who each lost a leg in a vehicular accident, against Kyle Best, the driver of the other vehicle, and his friend Shannon Colonna, to whom Best had sent a text seconds before the crash. The Kuberts settled with Best out of court, but took further action against Colonna, claiming that she had sent a text message while knowing the recipient was driving and likely to read the text. A trial court ruled that Colonna, as the sender of a text message to a driver, did not bear responsibility for the crash. But the Superior Court reversed, holding that the sender of a text may be found liable for a resultant car accident. Kubert v. Best, 2013 N.J. Super. LEXIS 132. Though the Superior Court absolved Colonna of responsibility for this particular accident, Americans have reason to be alarmed by the new rule laid down by the court. The appeals court used an analogy to explain its reasoning. The majority considered the issue of "whether a passenger can be liable not for actually obstructing the driver's view but only for urging the driver to take his eyes off the road and to look at a distracting object," and concluded that "the answer is yes" if the passenger expects to cause the driver to be negligent. Then, by analogy, the Court concluded that a person who sends a text, knowing that the recipient is likely driving and will likely read the text immediately, can be held liable for an accident. But sending a text message to a remote driver is very different from a passenger's deliberate distraction of the car's driver. Justice Espinosa dissented by pointing out that a remote texter "lacks the firsthand knowledge of the circumstances attendant to the driver's operation of the vehicle that a passenger possesses." Expanding responsibility for accidents to far-away correspondents is a step onto a slippery slope. Since many smartphones alert their owners when a new email arrives, what is to protect the sender of an email from being held liable for a recipient's car crash? What if someone sends out an email to a large list of recipients, and knows that it is likely that at least one recipient is driving and will read the email immediately? Should law-abiding citizens refrain from sending out emails to large lists, because doing so might distract a driver? The Court's reasoning opens the door for legions of trial attorneys to bring new lawsuits. Moreover, the Superior Court's ruling unduly bypasses the legislative process. Although the New Jersey Legislature had passed laws against texting while driving, Justice Espinosa noted that "[w]e have nothing before us that reflects whether the Legislature considered legislation that would have imposed either civil liability or criminal penalties for a remote texter who sends a distracting text message to a driver." The New Jersey appellate court should not have overridden the will of the people to open the floodgates for new lawsuits.