The U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit recently decided that White House visitor logs can be withheld from the American public, thus overturning much of a lower court's ruling on the issue. A foundation named Judicial Watch had made a Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) request to obtain Obama administration logs from the Secret Service. After the Secret Service denied the request, a federal district court held that the logs must be provided. The Secret Service appealed, and the Court of Appeals ruled that many of the logs could be kept secret. Judicial Watch, Inc. v. United States Secret Service, 2013 U.S. App. LEXIS 18119 (Aug. 30, 2013).
FOIA requires government agencies, such as the Secret Service, to release their "agency records" upon appropriate request. However, the visitor logs dealt with the Office of the President, which does not fall under FOIA. The district court used a special four-factor test to conclude that the requested documents were Secret Service "agency records" and thus had to be released.
The appellate court did not definitively negate the district court's conclusion on any of the four factors. Rather, it agreed in full on two, and portrayed the other two as gray areas. The court concluded that "if the four-factor test were the only relevant consideration, we would be left with an uncertain result. That uncertainty would redound to the benefit of Judicial Watch."
Even though it agreed that the four-factor approach would lead to the release of the visitor logs, the Court of Appeals ruled that key logs could be withheld. It did so by introducing two new arguments, each of which is ominous for governmental accountability.
First, the court dramatically expanded an existing exception. It wrote that, by legal precedent, "the standard, four-factor control test does not apply to documents that an agency has either obtained from, or prepared in response to a request from . . . the United States Congress." Relying on its prior ruling in a case called United We Stand, the court said that "in such cases" the key issue is "'whether Congress manifested a clear intent to control the document.'" This exception coexists with intrinsic safeguards: Congress consists of many popularly elected members, and citizens can thus control secrecy levels at the ballot box.
The court boldly asserted that the White House should have an exception just like the one for Congress. It wrote, "[i]f anything, the indicia of White House control in this case are even stronger than the indicia of congressional control in United We Stand." But secret meetings with the President likely have greater immediate impacts than do those with Congress, and the court's casual substitution of the former for the latter is reckless. Americans should be able to find out whether their President promoted a dangerous international agenda or met with powerful interest groups.
The appellate court's second way to avoid the lower court's framework was based on "the canon of avoiding constitutional . . . concerns." The appellate court was afraid that, if it allowed the visitor logs to be released, constitutional rights of the Office of the President would be violated. It stated, "the Executive has a 'constitutional prerogative' to '. . . safeguard the confidentiality of its communications.'" The Framers would be shocked to hear the court use the Constitution to prioritize Presidential secrecy over citizens' rights to transparency. The appellate court should have let stand the lower court's holding for the release of visitor logs.