One of the bad bills that this Congress passed was to convert our patent laws from a "first to invent" into a "first to file" system. Called the "America Invents Act," this new law turned 200 years of the most successful patent system in the world upside down.
For more than two centuries the rule has been that it is the person who first invents something who has priority in patenting it. This longstanding rule ensured that patent rights attach to the inventor, not to the paper-pushers who may file first with a government office.
But wait. A real inventor has filed suit against this new law, pointing out that it is unconstitutional, and he has top legal talent to back up his claims. Stadnyk v. U.S. PTO(M.D. Fla., No. 8:12-cv-01589-SDM-MAP. The inventor is Mark Stadnyk, and his arguments make perfect sense. His lawsuit explains that the Framers of the Constitution rejected Congress's new system whereby government can redefine who is the inventor, based on when and who filed paperwork with a government office.
"Others took on ObamaCare, and this is my fight," stated Stadnyk to the New York Times. Stadnyk went on to say that "somebody's gotta do something."
Stadnyk himself holds an important motorcycle patent, and is recognized as a significant inventor. Most innovation throughout our history has come from individuals working on their own, typically in their garages or small businesses or laboratories rather than under the direction of large corporations. American innovation would grind to a halt if multi-billion-dollar industries took control of all inventions.
The Segway, one of the most striking inventions of the 21st century, was not developed by a large corporation but by Dean Kamen, an independent inventor who personifies Yankee ingenuity. He lives in rural New Hampshire, and started "FIRST" as a program to encourage a million youngsters to become inventors and engineers. They should not be denied their rightful ownership of their inventions simply because an army of well-paid attorneys beat them to the patent office.
Bravo that Stadnyk is standing up against the unconstitutional law passed by Congress and signed by President Obama. The Founders of our great Nation inserted the unique patent clause into the Constitution to protect and encourage invention, not bureaucratic gamesmanship.