Court Monitor • Feb 25, 2013

Nativity Scene Expelled after 60 Years

Text Reader

For 60 years a nativity scene graced a public park in Santa Monica, California, a trendy California town that has grown increasingly liberal over the years. But actions of opponents of displays of Christianity on public property have driven the famous nativity scene out of the town's main public park. Opposition to this nativity scene last year resulted in a public lottery for the 21 display locations in the public park, and atheists won the right to choose the displays at 18 out of the 21 locations. The Santa Monica city council then decided in June to ban the nativity and other unattended displays entirely from the public park. The practical result was to prohibit a display of Christianity on public property during the Christmas season. An atheist leader of the opposition to the nativity scene denies trying to drive it out of the park, and asserts that he merely wanted to create equal protection of the law. But is it equal protection of the law for a small percentage of the population -- atheists -- to cause the silencing on public land of a large percentage of the population -- Christians? A group supporting the nativity scene then sued in federal court to allow it to continue its display as it has been for 60 years. Its attorney observed, "religious speech enjoys as much protection in public places as secular speech." The Christian group sought a preliminary injunction to allow display of the nativity scene this year. But the federal court denied this motion. It ruled that the nativity scene may be displayed on private property, but not in Santa Monica's biggest public park. Symbols of Christianity have always existed on public property, ranging from the Ten Commandments at the U.S. Supreme Court to "In God We Trust" on coins minted by the United States Treasury. The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, considered the most liberal in the nation, even denied an attempt to purge "under God" from the Pledge of Allegiance. Bit by bit, however, atheists continue to gain ground in the courts, the public schools, and city councils. An unrelenting drive to expel Christianity from the public square continues its march, with the practical effect of marginalizing Christianity in America. The City hopes its policy will withstand judicial review because it banned all unattended displays, regardless of content, and did not single out the nativity scene for censorship. But the history of the City's action demonstrates that it was motivated by the vocal opposition to the nativity scene. Speech that may offend some is allowed, and even protected, every day in public places. No one could censor a speech by someone else in a public place simply by claiming that it was offensive. Religious speech should receive the same First Amendment safeguards as, for example, violent video games, which the U.S. Supreme Court has been solicitous in protecting no matter how offensive they are. The attorney for the church group vowed to appeal.