Homeowners associations impose fees in private communities. The Mariner's Cove Townhomes Association, located in New Orleans, Louisiana, is one of many examples. It earns fees from a community consisting of 58 townhomes near Lake Pontchartrain and the 17th Street Canal. As with most homeowners associations, a restrictive covenant on the property gives the association the legal right to impose and collect fees from the homeowners.
After Hurricane Katrina ravaged the area, the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers worked on fixing a damaged levee that was adjacent to Mariner's Cove. This government agency started building an improved pumping station at the 17th Street Canal, and decided to acquire 14 out of the 58 units at Mariner's Cove by eminent domain, in order to improve its access to the pumping station.
The Fifth Amendment ensures that no property shall be taken by the government unless "just compensation" is given to the property owner. Often, however, the "just compensation" does not fully replace the lost value for the property owner, as when location of a business is taken but the lost revenue of the business is not fully compensated.
The Mariner's Cove Townhomes Association (MCTA) sued the government for the loss in fees that it incurred due to the conversion of the homes to government property. The present value of that lost income could have totaled hundreds of thousands of dollars or more, when the future lost income is included.
Late January the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit ruled that the homeowners association had a valid property right in this money, but it had no right to "just compensation" under the Fifth Amendment when it was taken away. United States v. 0.073 Acres of land, 2013 U.S. App. LEXIS 1902 (5th Cir. Jan. 28, 2013).
"Having found that MCTA's right to collect assessments is a property interest, we now turn to the question whether it is compensable. One of the government's main arguments on appeal is that the loss of MCTA's assessment base was incidental to the condemnation, and thus barred by the consequential loss rule. We agree," the appellate court ruled.
The "consequential loss rule" denies compensation for losses that are merely a consequence of eminent domain, such as lost profits. The Court held that to allow the homeowners association's claim for lost fees "would unjustifiably burden the government's eminent domain power."
Two of the three judges on this panel were Democrat-appointed, and they trimmed back a good Ninth Circuit precedent which held that under the Fifth Amendment a restrictive covenant imposing a duty which runs with the land is a compensable interest under the Fifth Amendment. Adaman Mutual Water Co. v. United States, 278 F.2d 842 (9th Cir. 1960). But in this case of a homeowners association, the Fifth Circuit held that the property interest was merely contractual and not sufficiently connected with the development of the land: "if we were to recognize MCTA's right as compensable, we would give special status under the Takings Clause to what essentially is a contract, merely because it appears in a title document."