Court Monitor • Apr 13, 2013

Bizarre 9-0 Affirmance on Trademark Issue

Text Reader

The U.S. Supreme Court grants only 1% of petitions seeking its review, and even then it is typically to resolve a conflict between the various U.S. Courts of Appeals. It is rare for the Supreme Court to agree to hear a case where there is no conflict among lower courts, and rarer still for the Court then to affirm the lower court decision by a 9-0 vote. When that happens it begs this question: why did the Court take the case for appeal merely to rubber-stamp the decision below? But such a bizarre ruling recently occurred without any conflict by lower courts. The case concerned a challenge to a trademark owned by Nike: "Air Force 1." Nike had sued for trademark infringement against a shoe company having the unusual name of "Already, LLC." Reading about this case is like listening to Abbott and Costello's famous comic routine, "Who's on First?" Nike started the litigation by suing Already for trademark infringement against Nike's "Air Force 1" mark. Already then counterclaimed against Nike, asserting that Nike's trademark was invalid. Nike, probably fearing that a court might find its trademark to be invalid, then filed a surprise "covenant not to sue" in the litigation, and moved to dismiss the entire case. The district and appellate courts agreed with Nike that its "covenant not to sue" rendered the entire case moot, removing any "case or controversy" between the parties. As a result, Already already had assurances that Already could sell new shoes without interference by Nike's trademark, which Nike had already obtained, but Already was not happy with this. It had affidavits demonstrating that investment in its company was being limited due to the continued existence of the trademark by Nike, which Already felt was invalid. People were reluctant to risk their money by investing in Already, given the continued existence of that possibly invalid trademark by Nike. Enough, Already, the U.S. Supreme Court unanimously held. Already, LLC v. Nike, Inc., 184 L. Ed. 2d 553 (2013). The Court ruled that this lawsuit became moot once Nike promised not to take any action against Already, its distributors and customers. The Court reiterated that "where a party assumes a certain position in a legal proceeding, and succeeds in maintaining that position, he may not thereafter, simply because his interests have changed, assume a contrary position . . . ." Already was fully and forever protected by Nike's covenant not to sue, the Court held. A concurrence by four Justices may reveal who granted the petition to hear this case. Justice Kennedy, joined by Justices Thomas, Alito and Sotomayor, concurred with the judgment but expressed concern about the unusual "covenant not to sue" tactic used by Nike to avoid a challenge to its trademark. Nike, in essence, got away with using litigation to chill competition while avoiding a test of the validity of its trademark. Justice Kennedy, who has a background in economics, wrote in concurrence that "covenants are not automatic mechanisms for trademark holders to use courts to intimidate competitors without, at the same time, assuming the risk that their trademark will be found invalid and unenforceable."