Daniel Brewington has been sentenced to five years in jail for harshly criticizing the family court system. Brewington v. State, 2013 Ind. App. LEXIS 14 (Ind. Ct. App. Jan. 17, 2013).
It all started when his wife filed for divorce. Litigation proceeded in family court and, as is typical, the family court ruled for the wife despite how she was the one who filed for the divorce. The court used a clinical psychologist to perform an evaluation of the husband. The psychologist filed a report recommending that the ex-wife "be the sole custodian and primary residential parent." The reason given was because the couple was no longer communicating well, and supposedly that somehow made joint custody unworkable. The ex-husband Daniel Brewington objected to the report, to no avail.
Brewington, was understandably critical of the court and the psychologist. He started to let his opinion be known. Brewington referred to the psychologist as "a very dangerous man who abuses his power." Brewington then asked for, and received, a change in the judge to preside over his case.
But rulings became worse for Brewington. The new judge terminated all the ex-husband's visitations with his children "until he submitted to an evaluation by a court-approved mental health care provider."
The ex-husband filed a motion for relief from judgment, alleging that the judge had "conducted himself in a willful, malicious, and premeditated manner." The ex-husband, in his court papers, promised to post his pleading on the internet and invited the public to write letters complaining about the judge to an ethics authority, who turned out to be the judge's wife. Some members of the public then sent letters to the home of the judge and his ethics-authority wife. Brewington also posted materials highly critical of the clinical psychologist on his blog.
Perhaps the judge complained to a prosecutor about this, because Brewington was next indicted by a grand jury and convicted by an anonymous jury on three counts of intimidation, two as Class A misdemeanors and one as a Class D felony, under Ind. Code § 35-45-2-1; one count of attempted obstruction of justice, a Class D felony, Ind. Code §§ 35-44.1-2-2; 35-41-5-1; and one count of perjury, a Class D felony, Ind. Code § 35-44.1-2-1. He was sentenced to five years in prison.
The crime of intimidation includes expressing a threat to someone else of exposure to "hatred, contempt, disgrace, or ridicule" in order to place that person in fear of retaliation for a prior lawful act. The Indiana Court of Appeals affirmed this conviction with respect to comments Brewington made about the judge. The Court denied a challenge to the statute despite its obvious conflict with the First Amendment right of free speech, holding that "[a] statute is presumed constitutional until the party challenging its constitutionality clearly overcomes the presumption by a contrary showing."
This case now moves to the Indiana Supreme Court, where constitutional law expert Eugene Volokh has filed an amicus brief in support of the First Amendment and the ex-husband.