Court Monitor • Apr 27, 2013

Supreme Court Slaps Down Hospitals

Text Reader

Hospitals soak up a massive amount of spending each year, totaling roughly a half-trillion dollars, which is about the same amount expended by all public schools combined. But while public schools have accountability, public oversight, and checks and balances, hospitals have little transparency and virtually no public oversight. Amid this darkness, mushrooms have been growing. Hospitals' executives now routinely take multi-million-dollar compensation for themselves, while simultaneously pleading with the public and government for more and more handouts. The bigger the hospitals, the greater their revenue, and the more their administrations enriche themselves. This has led to a merger frenzy among hospitals. Only the Federal Trade Commission (FTC), which is authorized to enforce federal antitrust law against mergers that result in monopolies, stands in the way of conglomeration in the hospital industry to the detriment of competition. But for the past decade the FTC has been losing many of its cases in court against hospital mergers . . . until February. The FTC had objected to a merger between two hospitals in rural Georgia that would have created a monopoly. The merger had been authorized by local officials, and they argued successfully in court that they had "state action immunity" to enforcement of federal antitrust laws against them. Under this doctrine, federal antitrust laws do not apply to decisions by state officials even though the same decisions would be a violation if made by private companies. With high-powered legal talent and many millions, if not billions, of dollars at stake, the hospitals crushed the FTC in district court in Georgia, and then won a victory on appeal to the Eleventh Circuit. While the FTC appealed to the U.S. Supreme Court, the Eleventh Circuit even lifted a stay against the merger, and the hospitals proceeded to consummate their union. The case appeared moot because it had become a "done deal." But in an astounding reversal of fortune, the U.S. Supreme Court unanimously reversed the decision of the 11th Circuit (and district court), and held that the merger may violate antitrust laws despite being approved by local officials. FTC v. Phoebe Putney Health System, 133 S. Ct. 1003 (U.S. 2013). The Court held in favor of the FTC and abrogated "state action immunity," because the Georgia legislature had not clearly expressed an intent for hospitals to create a monopoly as contemplated by this merger. Justice Sonia Sotomayor, writing for the Court, held that "immunity will only attach to the activities of local governmental entities if they are undertaken pursuant to a clearly articulated and affirmatively expressed state policy to displace competition." But the hospitals did not wait for the High Court to decide, and after the decision the FTC found itself desperately attempting to undo a merger that was already complete. That is a bit like trying to unscramble an egg, but the FTC is going to try. Meanwhile, the decision breathes new life into the use of antitrust law to slow down the rapid consolidation that is occurring in the hospital industry.