A rare judicial bright spot is the strengthening of the Takings Clause, the provision in the Fifth Amendment requiring compensation when private property is "taken for public use." When government is required to pay for what it takes from citizens, government is less likely to take or interfere with it.
Claims for compensation against the federal government are handled by the Court of Federal Claims, and on appeal by the Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit, which sits in D.C. Across town, another appellate court in D.C., the U.S. Supreme Court, has taken an unusual interest in the Federal Circuit and repeatedly disagreed with it.
A beneficiary of this Beltway spat is the Takings Clause. The Federal Circuit had rendered a decision limiting its application, and the Supreme Court unanimously reversed (with one recusal). Arkansas Game & Fish Commission v. United States, 133 S. Ct. 511 (2012).
This case began in 2005, when an Arkansas Commission sued the United States for deviations in water management by the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, leading to flooding of Arkansas land during the tree-growing season. Specifically, federal manipulation of a dam for farmers resulted in flooding between 1993 and 1999 of certain timber-rich land in Arkansas. The Arkansas Commission sued for compensation for this "taking" of its property as caused by federally induced flooding. Evidence showed that between 1993 and 1999, flooding damaged the property an average of 91 days per year, more than 40% above the historical average.
The Court of Federal Claims agreed with the Arkansas Commission that owned the property, and ordered the United States to compensate it for its loss. But a 2-1 split decision by the Federal Circuit reversed, holding instead that government-induced flooding requires compensation under the Takings Clause only if the flooding is "permanent or inevitably recurring."
This case became a perfect storm for the benefit of property owners when it reached the U.S. Supreme Court, which has recently been prone to reverse decisions by the Federal Circuit. The damage to trees caused by the flooding is anathema to environmentalists who typically enjoy support by the left side of the Court, and the trampling on private property in the form of government-induced flooding piques the interest of the Court's right side. All came together to rule that the federal government must compensate the property owner for the damage caused by the flooding.
"The trees did not have the root systems necessary to sustain themselves," resulting in "catastrophic mortality," the Court lamented in quoting a finding of fact in the trial court. Moreover, "[t]he destruction of the trees led to the invasion of undesirable plant species, making natural regeneration of the forests improbable in the absence of reclamation efforts."
The Supreme Court ruled that temporary flooding caused by government is subject to the Takings Clause, thereby enabling property owners to recover just compensation for the damage caused.