On April 22, 2010, students at a public high school in Springfield, Missouri heard a chilling message over their public address system: their school was entering "lockdown" mode and students were ordered not to leave their classrooms.
Was a killer loose in another public school? No, not for this lockdown. This command over the school's public address system was for the benefit of a search by police, using drug-sniffing dogs, of the belongings of students and teachers.
"Random, suspicionless lockdown raids against children teach our children a horrific lesson -- one that goes against every fundamental principle this country was founded upon -- that we have no rights at all against the police state," observed John W. Whitehead, president of the Rutherford Institute. Yet this has become standard operating procedure in the Springfield, Missouri public school district.
The school district justifies its procedure based on the problem of drug use by students. Illegal drugs are rampant in many schools, even in the heartland of America. In central Missouri, this particular school district had 154 drug incidents in the school year -- nearly one new drug incident every school day.
After the lockdown was announced, students were ordered to leave their backpacks and all their belongings behind as a policeman with a drug-detecting dog stood outside. Then the dog entered and sniffed everything inside the classroom. No drugs were found during this particular search, but the Rutherford Institute filed a lawsuit on behalf of parents upset by it.
A federal district court in the Western District of Missouri dismissed this lawsuit by finding that the search did not violate the Fourth Amendment. The appeal went to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit.
The Eighth Circuit, in an opinion by Clinton-appointed Judge Diana Murphy, upheld this search as constitutional. Burlison v. Springfield Public Schools,2013 U.S. App. LEXIS 4378 (8th Cir. Mar. 4, 2013) "A student's privacy interest is limited in a public school environment where the State is responsible for maintaining discipline, health, and safety," the Court declared in reliance on Supreme Court precedent. The Court emphasized "that students have a lesser expectation of privacy than members of the population generally," again quoting Supreme Court precedent.
John Whitehead criticized the decision and the school policy. "Americans should be outraged over the fact that school officials are not only defending such clearly unconstitutional practices but are actually going so far as to insist that these raids are a 'standard drill' that will continue."
Though unaddressed by the Court, law-abiding students have reason to fear these raids. Police dogs are extremely sensitive to any trace of drugs, and it is predictable that drug users will cause trouble for others by handling their belongings. On March 26, 2013, a 5-4 ruling by the U.S. Supreme Court prohibited even a brief use of drug-detecting dogs by police in public at someone's front door, in the absence of a warrant. Florida v. Jardines, 2013 U.S. LEXIS 2542 (2013).
Surprise police raids with dogs are not the only way to address the drug problem in schools. Private high schools use private approaches that do not expand the power of the State. At Marquette High School in Alton, Illinois, students provide a personal hair sample to be tested for drug use. If the results are positive, then consultation with the parents follows. Confidentiality is preserved and test results are eventually destroyed rather than becoming part of the student's school record.