This lawsuit was a claim that the timber industry and state officials had not obtained necessary permits from the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) prior to engaging in logging activity in a Northwest forest. An environmentalist group argued that National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System (NPDES) permits were required, because the logging roads channeled stormwater into navigable U.S. waterways. A possible interpretation of EPA regulations is that this runoff water constitutes "point source pollution" similar to that of a factory, which requires an EPA permit before it can be done.
The timber industry and Oregon officials did not obtain this permit, and the Ninth Circuit agreed with an environmentalist group that this was a violation of EPA regulations. An appeal to the U.S. Supreme Court followed.
At issue was channeled stormwater runoff from two logging roads in Oregon's Tillamook State Forest, about 40 miles west of Portland. The logging activity along these roads has been performed by Georgia-Pacific West and others under a contract with the State of Oregon. When it rains there, it pours, sometimes exceeding 100 inches of rainfall per year. Roadside channels have been built to divert the excess water away from the logging roads into nearby streams and rivers, along with the inevitable dirt and crushed gravel. Some assert that this runoff can harm fish.
But the Obama Administration told the Court that this was not "point source pollution" requiring a federal permit, and the Supreme Court held that the agency's interpretation of its own regulations should govern. Decker v. Northwest Environmental Defense Center, 2013 U.S. LEXIS 2373 (Mar. 20, 2013)
The Court ruled that "an agency's interpretation need not be the only possible reading of a regulation -- or even the best one -- to prevail. When an agency interprets its own regulation, the Court, as a general rule, defers to it unless that interpretation is plainly erroneous or inconsistent with the regulation." The clean water regulation was intended for traditional industrial buildings, such as factories and other stationary facilities. In addition, the Court was impressed by how Congress wanted the EPA to work with State and local officials to alleviate stormwater pollution, something Oregon had been doing without the requirement of federal permits.
A surprising dissent by Justice Scalia indicated that he preferred a different result, one that would have forced the EPA to apply strictly the regulation that it had written. Justice Scalia dissented alone to protest how the Court was deferring to an agency's interpretation of its own regulation, calling this "a dangerous permission slip for the arrogation of power." As in other areas, Justice Scalia prefers to enforce the text of the regulation, rather than speculate about its hidden intent, and he felt that the regulatory text in this case did require permits for stormwater runoff.