By a 6-1 margin, the Louisiana Supreme Court struck down a complex school voucher program that was the pride and joy of Governor Bobby Jindal. Louisiana Federation of Teachers v. State, 2013 La. LEXIS 1077 (La. May 7, 2013). The successful plaintiffs in the action included - no surprise here - the public school teachers' unions.
This unfortunate ruling is a wake-up call to conservatives who have not focused as much on appointments to state courts as to federal courts. Savvy liberal groups are increasingly turning to state courts in southern jurisdictions, such as Louisiana and Oklahoma, to overturn conservative laws. It hardly matters to elect good people to state offices if the nominations to state courts are going to toss out the good laws they pass.
The Louisiana Constitution contains specific provisions about funding public school education in the State, which the Louisiana Supreme Court had previously interpreted to require that "each public school child in this state receives an equal educational opportunity regardless of the wealth of the parish in which the child resides." Louisiana Association of Educators v. Edwards, 521 So.2d 390, 391 (La. 1988) (citing verbatim transcripts of the 1973 Louisiana constitutional convention). For example, the State share of basic costs is not allowed to drop below 25% for any district.
The Louisiana Supreme Court majority struck down the voucher program by finding that it would "unconstitutionally divert [certain] funds to nonpublic entities in violation" of the Louisiana Constitution. In other words, it was the manner in which this program diverted funds from the public school system directly to private schools that was defective, in the view of the majority. Other voucher programs that give the money back to parents for their use in picking schools have been upheld elsewhere.
Only about 1% of eligible former public school students in Louisiana were using the vouchers this year, although that number was set to nearly double next year. Liberals objected to how many of the voucher students then attended private Christian schools that taught Young Earth Creationism rather than the atheistic curriculum pushed in public school.
Predictably, the Louisiana School Boards Association cheered the decision, which preserves the public school monopoly over taxpayer-funded education. For now, this decision stops an exodus of funding and students from the underachieving public schools in Louisiana, which repeatedly rank near the bottom in the nation in quality.
Judge Greg Guidry, in his lone dissent, disagreed with the majority's interpretation of the Louisiana Constitution and also invited the State to try again with a slightly different voucher program. He indicated that Louisiana can easily find other ways to fund the transfers of public school students to private schools without running afoul of the Court's decision.
The news is not entirely bad on this front. A few weeks earlier, the Indiana Supreme Court upheld Indiana's school voucher program because the money went to families for their use as they thought best, rather than directly to private schools on behalf of families.