The "Big Easy" is New Orleans, our nation's center for jazz and a laid-back, big city lifestyle. The origin of the catchy name is not known, but some have suggested that it is a play on the "Big Apple," contrasting the easygoingness of New Orleans with the stress of New York City.
One of the most popular restaurants in the Big Easy has long been the Camellia Grill, which ranks among the top 100 affordable eateries in the nation. Its menu features delectable dishes like "griddled pie," whereby a chef sears a slice of pie on the grill for awaiting customers. The waiters are entertaining and lines can be long as many tourists await seating. Night-owl college students pile in to keep it hopping.
But an ugly dispute over the famous name of this restaurant is forcing its current owner to rename the landmark. This dispute illustrates how someone can be forced to change the name of his own business on his own property.
This popular hangout is located near the bustling intersection of St. Charles and Carrollton. The owner has been successful enough to open a second restaurant under the same name in the French Quarter. But he was sued by a prior owner of the restaurant for allegedly violating a licensing agreement concerning the famous name. The prior owner won this lawsuit in state court in Louisiana, and won again on appeal in May 2013.
This conflict illustrates how the ownership of a business and a location is not the same as owning a name. The ownership of the building in which the Camellia Grill has long been located, on South Carrollton Street, is clear and undisputed. No one can take that location away from the current owner without his consent.
But the name "Camellia Grill" still belongs to the prior owner, who held onto his rights to the famous name when he sold the business in 2006. He licensed the name to the current owner, and if and when that licensing agreement is violated, then the right of the current owner to use the name ends.
Hicham Khodr, the current owner of the restaurant, apparently obtained the rights to use "Camellia Grill" provided he made certain payments and did not use an altered logo. But Khodr was allegedly late in sending a small payment, and supposedly used an altered version of the logo, and this violated the agreement and enabled the licensor to terminate the license. It is unclear if Khodr ever realized that he might lose the rights to the famous name on such a basis.
As a result, a perplexed public accustomed for decades to going to the Camellia Grill will find a restaurant by a different name there. It is unlikely that a similar-sounding name would be allowed. This legal dispute over a landmark in the Big Easy shows it is not entirely easygoing.