Court Monitor • Aug 29, 2013

Colorado Supreme Court Halts School Spending Increase

Text Reader

American public schools spend an astonishing $10,000 per student each year. In Colorado, however, public schools are slightly more reasonable, spending $2,000 per pupil below the national average. In 2005, a liberal education group, unhappy with the relatively low school spending in Colorado, sued the state. The group cited the Colorado constitution's requirement that the state provide a "thorough and uniform education," arguing that the state did not spend enough money to make education thorough and uniform. Though public-school expenditures were already high, the liberal activists wanted to use the state constitution to spend even more taxpayer money. A Colorado Court of Appeals agreed with the plaintiffs, holding that the funding system for public education in Colorado was somehow not "rationally related" to the Colorado constitution's "thorough anduniform" requirement, and thus unconstitutional. But that view is preposterous, since the state constitution's requirement was clearly not meant to prohibit Colorado school expenditures from falling below the national average. The state appealed to the Colorado Supreme Court, which on May 28, 2013 overturned the Court of Appeals decision, holding that the funding is "rationally related to the 'thorough and uniform' mandate." The Court of Appeals did not explain what "thorough and uniform" means, and the Supreme Court defined it as referring to "a free public school system that is of a quality marked by completeness, is comprehensive, and is consistent across the state." With this obvious meaning of the phrase "thorough and uniform," there was no way to find a violation of the Colorado constitution. The constitutional provision was meant to protect against regional biases in the state-run public school system, and to preclude situations of grossly insufficient resources. It was not meant to force the state to emulate the spending excesses of other states' school systems. The Court recognized these principles, arguing that the constitutionality of school-funding laws does not imply that they "provide an optimal amount of money to the public schools." The Court concluded that any so-called optimal amount of funding, be it high or low, is not necessitated by the state constitution. Abiding by judicial restraint and preventing the court system from increasing school funding levels and the corresponding tax rates, the Colorado Supreme Court rightfully respected the rights of individuals to vote on such issues. The Court also mentioned "the importance of local control to the . . . public school financing system." Local control is essential to reducing the possibility of overreach by a centralized governmental authority. Local control also gives options to parents, as they can move to a nearby school district if they are not satisfied with the quality of their children's instruction. The Court acknowledged the importance of having options, writing that "local control provides . . . a healthy competition for educational excellence." The Colorado Supreme Court's ruling is in accord with the proper role of constitutional interpretation. Just as the U.S. Constitution is meant to protect the states and the people from the federal government, so the state constitutions are meant to protect the local governments and the people from the state. The plaintiffs sought to use the state constitution to require the state to override decisions of the people, which is not what the constitution was intended to do.