Court Monitor • Sep 11, 2013

Blind Eye toward Alien Voting

Text Reader

In 2004, Arizona passed Proposition 200, which required election officials to demand proof of citizenship when registering voters. Voters have always been required to be citizens. But the requirement had not been enforced under the Clinton-backed National Voter Registration Act (NVRA). The NVRA only required prospective voters to sign a statement claiming citizenship. The people of Arizona demanded real enforcement, and 56% voted for Proposition 200. Liberal groups challenged the Arizona law in federal court and were successful. Arizona appealed to the Supreme Court, which invalidated Proposition 200 with a 7-2 ruling in Arizona v. Inter Tribal Council of Arizona, Inc. The Court held that Proposition 200 contradicts the NVRA and the NVRA preempts Proposition 200. The Court relied on the NVRA's requirement that states "accept and use" a specific voter-registration form. The Court held that, since documentation of citizenship is not required by the form, Proposition 200 would cause Arizona election officials to not "accept and use" the federally defined form. Proposition 200, however, does not prohibit election officials from using the NVRA form. It simply requires additional documentation. The claim that adding requirements makes the original form not "accept[ed] and use[d]" is dubious. Justice Thomas wrote in his dissent that he "would construe the law as only requiring Arizona to accept and use the form as part of its voter registration process." Since Proposition 200 does allow for the form's use alongside of citizenship documentation, it does not necessarily conflict with the NVRA. A legal principle called the "presumption against preemption" tells judges to assume that a federal law does not preempt a state law, unless the opposite is clear. If there is any doubt about whether Proposition 200 violates the NVRA, the presumption against preemption should lead the courts to allow the state law to stand. Justice Alito, in his dissent, discussed a 1917 Supreme Court ruling which noted that "the policy of Congress" was "to leave the conduct of the election of its members to state laws, administered by state officers," with federal regulation "by positive and clear statutes." The majority opinion of the Court was not in accord with this presumption against preemption. Far from being preempted by federal law, Proposition 200 enforces a voter requirement that follows directly from the Constitution itself. The Constitution requires that voters in federal elections must meet the qualifications for voting for "the most numerous Branch of the State Legislature." Arizona requires voters in elections for its most numerous legislative branch to be citizens. Thus, Proposition 200 ensures that Arizona law complies with federal requirements, and claiming that a contradiction with federal requirements nullifies the law is absurd. While the Court's arguments for invalidating Proposition 200 are flawed, its suggested practical approach to ensuring that voters are citizens is even worse. The majority opinion states that Arizona could ask the Election Assistance Commission (EAC) to implement better checks of citizenship. But all four EAC positions are currently vacant, so the EAC is unlikely to be helpful to Arizona. The federal government should stop getting in the way of state-level enforcement of voter eligibility rules.