Court Monitor • Jan 14, 2014

Judicial Supremacists Impose Same-Sex Marriage in New Jersey

Text Reader

The New Jersey Supreme Court has overturned the will of the people by forcing the State to issue same sex marriage licenses, even though the Governor and legislature never authorized this redefinition of marriage. Making matters worse, the Court used flawed arguments to trample on actual legislation, resorting instead to emotional appeals and specious reasoning. This decision illustrates the dangers of oppressive decrees by unelected judges. Same-sex marriage is now the law in about one third of the United States. The next states targeted for adopting same-sex marriage are, in this order of likelihood: New Mexico, Oregon, Michigan, Virginia, Nevada, and then Colorado, Ohio, Utah, and Pennsylvania. Judicial supremacy, as used in the New Jersey opinion, is advancing the liberal agenda. The New Jersey Supreme Court imposed same sex marriage by pretending that there is a collective right of couples in homosexual relationships. Garden State Equality v. Dow, 2013 N.J. LEXIS 1091 (Oct. 18, 2013). This decision ruled that "because State law offers same-sex couples civil unions but not the option of marriage, same-sex couples in New Jersey are now being deprived of the full rights and benefits the State Constitution guarantees." But the New Jersey Constitution does not guarantee any rights to couples. Instead, it guarantees rights to individuals, and defining marriage to be between one man and one woman does not violate any such personal right. The New Jersey Supreme Court rejected each of the State's arguments against the imposition of same-sex marriage. An attorney for the State properly argued that homosexual couples "will not be able to overcome the highest presumption of constitutional validity that attaches to statutory enactments" that preserve the traditional definition of marriage. The State's opposition to same-sex marriage makes sense: if there is any doubt regarding the constitutionality of a law, the courts should err on the side of respecting the democratic process, and thus should let the law that does not impose same-sex marriage stand. The Court did not seriously address this presumption against unconstitutionality. Instead, it held that because the U.S. Supreme Court had recently ordered that federal benefits be granted to same-sex couples who are married under state law, the civil union law in New Jersey was inadequate to ensure that homosexual couples in New Jersey are able to receive the same benefits as married couples. Due to the U.S. Supreme Court decision, the New Jersey Supreme Court held that same-sex marriage must be allowed to avoid any possible lack of benefits for same-sex couples. By deferring to federal law when it advances the homosexual agenda, the New Jersey Supreme Court tossed out several millennia of success attributable to the limitation of marriage to one man and one woman. Procedurally, the Court authorized the performance of same-sex marriages beginning on October 21, 2013. Governor Chris Christie could have continued to fight for traditional marriage, however, as the case was remanded back to the trial court for further deliberations. But Governor Christie caved in, and allowed the homosexual agenda to win on this issue without further opposition by the State. There was no dissent from the New Jersey Court's ruling, not even by Christie's own judicial appointments. But millions of Americans are dissenting with their feet, by moving away from same-sex marriage states and into the many states that continue to recognize the value of marriage as being between only one man and one woman.