Court Monitor • Jan 25, 2014

Victory for Companies Objecting to an Obamacare Mandate

Text Reader

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit has delivered a stunning ruling in favor of business owners who object to the Obamacare mandate requiring them to provide abortifacients and contraceptives for employees. The D.C. Circuit even observed that some contraceptives are considered to be carcinogenic by the World Health Organization, and thus can be detrimental to women's health. The brilliant decision was rendered by Judge Janice Brown, whose opinion won the support of fellow Judge Raymond Randolph for a 2-1 majority. Gilardi v. HHS, 2013 U.S. App. LEXIS 22256 (D.C. Cir. Nov. 1, 2013). The issue will likely be addressed again by the U.S. Supreme Court in 2014. Judge Brown has long been a defender of liberty. From 1996 to 2005, she served on the California Supreme Court, where she championed conservative principles. She wrote an opinion defending the right of Catholic Charities to adhere to religious beliefs and omit contraceptive coverage for employees. She also defended a California law that requires parental notification when minors have abortions. Liberals hate Judge Brown so much that they stalled her nomination to the D.C. Circuit Court of Appeals for two years. In Gilardi v. HHS, Judge Brown dismantled the nonsensical liberal claim that the mandate affects only those seeking contraception coverage. She wrote that "[t]he burden on religious exercise does not occur at the point of contraceptive purchase; instead, it occurs when a company's owners fill the basket of goods and services that constitute a healthcare plan." Since the mandate directly interferes with the owners' decisions about what to include, the Court held, it infringes on religious liberty. Judge Brown made clear that this governmental restriction on religious freedom was no small matter: if the business owners "abide by the sacred tenets of their faith," she wrote, they would have to "pay a penalty of over $14 million . . . crippl[ing] the companies they have spent a lifetime building." The Obama administration had claimed that any loss of freedom was experienced by the company, not the owners. This argument gave liberals a way to contravene religious liberty protections while pretending they were not violating people's rights. Judge Brown referred to it as "the government's shell game." She wrote, "we are satisfied that the" company's owners "have been injured in a way that is separate and distinct from an injury to the corporation." Judge Brown cut through liberal semantics to defend religious liberty. Judge Brown observed that the "corporate veil" generally does not trample on individual rights, but rather that, when "shareholders forgo certain rights pertaining to the corporation . . . [s]hareholders make such a sacrifice because the corporation can generally exercise some analogue of the forgone right." Thus, if business owners passed some of their religious rights to a corporation, we would expect the corporation itself to be entitled to religious freedom. Judge Brown suggested that perhaps the companies' "constitutional arithmetic, Citizens United plus the Free Exercise Clause, equals a corporate free-exercise right, will ultimately prevail." (Citizens United was the decision that gave corporations a right to spend money in political campaigns.) Regardless of whether this "constitutional arithmetic" will prevail, the Court's ruling against an Obamacare mandate is a breath of fresh air.