Court Monitor • Feb 26, 2014

Third Circuit Rejects Warrantless GPS Tracking

Text Reader

The Third Circuit U.S. Court of Appeals has stood up for the Fourth Amendment rights of citizens. On October 22, 2013, the Court ruled that evidence obtained from a GPS device that police secretly placed on a suspect's van was not admissible, because the warrantless tracking violated the suspect's constitutional protection against unreasonable search and seizure. USA v. Katzin, 732 F.3d 187 (3d Cir. 2013). The FBI affixed a GPS tracking device to the exterior of a Philadelphia electrician's van. The FBI did not have a warrant, and the vehicle's owner was not present and was unaware of the FBI's action. The federal government claimed that the tracking was reasonable to investigate some local burglaries. But if it was reasonable and appropriate, then the FBI should have obtained a warrant first. It did not. The Third Circuit observed that "the Supreme Court has compared" GPS tracking "to 'a constable's concealing himself in the target's coach in order to track its movements.'" If federal agents had physically hidden in the van to watch its movements, they would clearly be violating the owner's Fourth Amendment rights, and using a GPS tracker is not substantially different. The Court also addressed the "automobile exception," which was developed in previous cases to allow police to search a vehicle without a warrant under certain circumstances. The rationale is that, if an officer suspects that certain evidence is inside an automobile, it would make sense for him to quickly look inside to find the evidence before it disappeared. But, as the Court noted, such a "search is still limited to a discrete moment in time." GPS tracking is entirely different, the majority continued, because it "creates a continuous police presence for the purpose of discovering evidence that may come into existence and/or be placed within the vehicle." Perhaps realizing that its arguments were weak, the federal government cited decisions by other circuits in a feeble attempt to defend secret monitoring. Several circuits had ruled that GPS tracking does not require a warrant, but the D.C. Circuit had ruled that a warrant is necessary. The Third Circuit was not satisfied by the government's selective focus on those decisions that allowed warrantless surveillance, and wrote that "the Government seems to argue that reliance on a majority of a minority of our sister circuits is sufficient to escape" the dismissal of evidence gained from GPS tracking. "This cannot be." The Court drove home the broader significance of the issues at hand. "Where an officer decides to take the Fourth Amendment inquiry into his own hands, rather than to seek a warrant," the majority wrote, "he acts in a constitutionally reckless fashion." As technology proliferates, so does the potential for the federal government to become the pervasive Big Brother that George Orwell warned against. New cybercrimes are being invented in order to hand out long prison sentences. For example, federal prosecutors wanted to imprison activist Aaron Swartz for 35 years for making scientific research available online to the public, imposing pressure that may have contributed to the young man's suicide shortly before trial. The Framers never intended for federal investigatory and prosecutorial power to be unlimited.