Court Monitor • Feb 3, 2014

Vermont Supreme Court Forces Church Camp to Pay Taxes

Text Reader

The Vermont Supreme Court has forced a church camp to pay property taxes. This decision is the latest example of government intrusion on religious freedom, and puts many church projects at risk of being destroyed by taxation. The church camp seeks "to share the Gospel of Jesus Christ . . . through various ministries consistent with the Holy Scriptures," which is a traditionally tax-exempt purpose. The camp was even run by a Christian church, the Brownington Center Church. Founded in 1997, the camp has been tax-exempt for years. But in 2008, the town of Irasburg reevaluated the church's property-tax exemption and then demanded taxes. The government's determination was based on a law passed by the Vermont legislature. The Vermont law had eliminated some religious tax exemptions, but probably no one imagined that it would be used to deny tax exemption to a religious camp. Yet that is precisely what the Vermont Supreme Court held on October 25th, when it ordered the religious camp to pay property taxes dating back to 2009. Brownington Center Church v. Town of Irasburg, 2013 VT 99 (2013). This is a devastating blow to a church that was generously providing charitable services for children, and that benefited society far more than government spending does. The Vermont legislation did not necessarily require that the camp be taxed. Indeed, the law actually exempted church edifices from taxation. Brownington Center Church (now known as New Hope Bible Church and Ministries) argued in court that the structures on its campsite were church edifices because they were used to propagate a religious message. The Vermont Supreme Court should have recognized that the religious nature of the camp warranted a tax exemption. Instead, the court held that the legislation's lack of detail relating to church camps implied the absence of an exemption. The court narrowly focused on the fact that the law did not explicitly mention church camp-type situations while stipulating that "a building used as a convent, school, orphanage, home or hospital" would be tax-exempt. The court expanded taxation against churches as much as it possibly could under the law. The Vermont Supreme Court acknowledged the group's belief "that the Church is the body of believers in Christ and not a physical structure." The court was then dismissive of the church by ruling that the "the core beliefs of any pious religious society cannot shape the logical interpretation of the taxation statute." Will any religious activity be safe from taxation in the future? The court's rejection of the church's "core beliefs" does not separate religion from government, but rather forces the government's definition of church upon a religious group. One wonders whether this ruling infringes on the First Amendment rights of churches to be exempt from taxation, an issue that was not addressed by the decision. The Vermont Supreme Court should have recognized that the religious camp merited a tax exemption under state law. To the extent the law was ambiguous, the court should have sided with religious freedom rather than against it. What other types of church property will be taxed next?