Court Monitor • Mar 10, 2014

Judicial Supremacy Smacks Pennsylvania

Text Reader

Pennsylvania is a "Rust Belt" state that suffered enormously from the loss of manufacturing jobs. But recently it found a new source of jobs with development of the Marcellus Shale, a vast deposit of natural gas underneath the closed factories and farmland that speckle her landscape. Thanks to energy development such as "fracking," a process that harvests underground natural gas, many struggling Pennsylvania towns are undergoing an economic revival. The adjacent States of New York and New Jersey ban fracking due to pressure by environmentalists, but the Republican legislature in Pennsylvania passed a law prohibiting local town ordinances from interfering with it. In the late 1800s, Williamsport, Pennsylvania, was one of the wealthiest cities in the nation. But Williamsport declined as industry moved away, and survived as best it could by hosting the Little League World Series each summer and relying on tourism to generate a modicum of income. Now Williamsport is thriving again with the benefits of energy development in its area. Energy exploration and production of natural gas in Pennsylvania has resulted in many good new jobs, and lower prices for consumers everywhere. Pennsylvania's energy production has increased to supply roughly 10% of all the natural gas that our entire nation uses. Pennsylvanians are better off from the new jobs, and all Americans benefit, thanks to the lower cost of natural gas that heats many homes in the winter. Pennsylvania energy developers have even discovered "wet" gas there, which contains valuable gas liquids like ethane, an essential ingredient in plastics. But wait. Environmentalists oppose energy production, and they want fracking stopped in Pennsylvania just as it has been banned in neighboring northeastern states. The elected legislature disagrees with the environmentalist demands. But why wait for a political change in the legislature, when liberals can get courts to repeal legislation they don't like? Environmentalists sued, demanding that courts reverse what the statehouse achieved in encouraging the energy development. And voilà, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court became the judicial supremacists that the environmentalists wanted, striking down the 2012 state law that welcomed the energy development. Robinson Twp. v. Commonwealth, 2013 Pa. LEXIS 3068 (Dec. 19, 2013). The Court relied on an "Environmental Rights Amendment" to the Pennsylvania Constitution (Article I, Section 27), which guarantees "a right to clean air, pure water, and the preservation of the natural, scenic, historic and esthetic values of the environment." This illustrates why vague constitutional amendments are dreadful invitations for courts to legislate from the bench. On the basis of that feel-good environmentalist provision in the state constitution, the Court invalidated "Act 13," which had prevented local governments from using their zoning powers to interfere with energy development. In Houston, where job growth is booming and unemployment is substantially lower than the national average, there are no zoning restrictions. The free market can work its magic there, but no longer in Pennsylvania with respect to energy production. The margin of victory for the environmentalists was only 4-2, with one Justice recusing herself. The dissenting Justices expressed their dismay at how the Court usurped the role of the legislature. "We should not complain of incursions on judicial independence and of refusals to respect our role when we in turn act legislatively," concluded Justice Eakin in dissent.