Court Monitor • Mar 18, 2014

Sherlock Holmes Loses His Copyright

Text Reader

Sherlock Holmes, the clever detective created by Sir Arthur Conan Doyle, has undergone a revival in literary works, television shows, and movies long after Doyle passed away in 1930. The heirs of Holmes' creator want a piece of the pie, and the Conan Doyle estate invokes copyright law to prevent unauthorized uses of Holmes and his famous sidekick, Dr. Watson. The original Sherlock Holmes was a master of detail and deductive reasoning from clues that went unnoticed by Scotland Yard and readers. His incisive mind has influenced millions and even guided judges in real cases. Here is an example from Silver Blaze, a Conan Doyle story relating to the disappearance of a valuable racehorse in the middle of the night: The plodding Scotland Yard detective (Gregory: "Is there any point to which you would wish to draw my attention?" Sherlock Holmes: "To the curious incident of the dog in the night-time." Gregory: "The dog did nothing in the night-time." Holmes: "That was the curious incident." By recognizing the significance of the "dog that didn't bark," Holmes solved the mystery: someone known to the dog, the horse's trainer, was the person who took the horse away. Doyle wrote Silver Blaze in 1892, which means its copyright has expired, and it is freely available on the internet for anyone to read today at websites such as Gutenberg.org. Indeed, copyright has expired on all of Doyle's works in Britain, but not yet in the United States, where copyright still exists for works created since 1923. Works published and copyrighted between 1923 and 1977 retain their copyright protection for 95 years, which means the oldest will not enter the public domain (and become freely available) until 2019. Ten of the Sherlock Holmes short stories were published after 1923, and thus remain protected by copyright in the United States. But the 46 short stories and four novels that Doyle published prior to 1923 have completely lost their copyright protection and are in the public domain. When Leslie S. Klinger and a co-author found a publisher for their new work In the Company of Sherlock Holmes, the Conan Doyle Estate, Ltd. warned the publisher Pegasus Books that the estate would "not hesitate" to demand that Amazon.com and Barnes & Noble exclude the book if unauthorized by the Conan Doyle Estate. Fearing litigation, Pegasus Books then refused to publish In the Company of Sherlock Holmes. Klinger next sued in federal court in northern Illinois to obtain a declaratory judgment to determine the copyright status of specific "characters, character traits, dialogue, settings, artifacts, and other story elements" in the Sherlock Holmes collection of stories. In response, the Doyle estate insisted that because ten short stories remain protected by copyright in the United States, copyright prevents reuse of the character of Sherlock Holmes without permission from the estate, which would presumably demand royalties in exchange for allowing it. Not so fast, a federal court has ruled. Klinger v. Conan Doyle Estate, Ltd., 2013 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 180493 (N.D. Ill. Dec. 23, 2013). Using deductive reasoning of which Holmes himself would have been proud, federal judge Ruben Castillo ruled that pre-1923 characters of Sherlock Holmes and Dr. Watson have passed into the public domain, and can be freely and fully used in new literary works without interference by copyright. Only new characteristics introduced in the final ten short stories, such as Dr. Watson's athletic background or his second marriage, may be prohibited by the estate based on copyright. And that result is...elementary, my dear Watson!