Court Monitor • Mar 28, 2014

Court Revives "Relic of Barbarism"

Text Reader

The Republican Party was founded on the goal of abolishing barbarism in territories of the United States as Americans migrated westward. The first national platform of the Republican Party, in 1856, declared that "it is both the right and the imperative duty of Congress to prohibit in the Territories those twin relics of barbarism -- Polygamy, and Slavery." Later Republicans pushed through a law that even disincorporated The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints until it repudiated polygamy, which it subsequently did. From the earliest moments in English history, polygamy has been prohibited as a crime against all of society, punishable by the death penalty. The United States upheld laws against polygamy in Reynolds v. United States, 98 U.S. 145 (1878), observing that "there never has been a time in any State of the Union when polygamy has not been an offence against society, cognizable by the civil courts and punishable with more or less severity." Yet polygamy is back, due to judicial supremacy that knows no bounds of decency. A celebrity who promotes a polygamous lifestyle on television sued to establish a right for him to cohabit with multiple women, who are called "sister wives." He went into federal court and sought a declaration that he somehow has a constitutional right to live in this polygamous-like arrangement. The only thing missing from formal polygamy is a marriage license with each of the women; he officially married only one, but unofficially cohabits with all four of them. Together they raise 16 children. Utah law prohibited cohabitation arrangements that mimic polygamy: "A person is guilty of bigamy when, knowing he has a husband or wife or knowing the other person has a husband or wife, the person purports to marry another person or cohabits with another person." Utah Code Ann. § 76-7-101. But a federal judge invalidated the "or cohabits with another person" part, thereby allowing the equivalence of polygamous relationships as long as there are not multiple formal marriages with certificates. Brown v. Buhman, 2013 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 175443 (D. Utah Dec. 13, 2013). Building to his shocking conclusion, the federal judge first portrayed Anglo-American opposition to polygamy as being historically racist, supposedly born of prejudice against eastern and African cultures that have welcomed polygamy. The court then held that there is a constitutional right to polygamous relationships based on three independent grounds: the First Amendment right to free exercise of religion, a constitutional right to engage in sex as established by the U.S. Supreme Court in Lawrence v. Texas for homosexual conduct, and a due process right against vague laws that can lead to arbitrary enforcement. These three separate reasons were given by the court to justify its ruling in favor of polygamous relationships. Why the deafening silence from feminists, from whom one might expect to hear the loudest protest? Perhaps because they are not pro-women, but anti-traditional family. So the burden falls on Republican-appointed appellate judges to overturn this ruling that there is a constitutional right to one of the "twin relics of barbarism."