In a stunning conservative victory, a federal judge upheld the power of states to force a federal agency to include a proof-of-citizenship requirement on its voter registration forms.
Until now, the federal voter registration form has only required someone registering to vote to indicate U.S. citizenship by checking a box. Illegal aliens lie to enter this country, and there is no protection against their lying to register to vote.
But a brilliant law drafted by Kansas Secretary of State Kris Kobach, as enacted by both Arizona and Kansas, orders the federal government to include a requirement that anyone registering to vote also provide proof of citizenship, such as a birth certificate or passport.
Despite lacking a quorum, the federal Election Assistance Commission said "no," and refused to comply with the state laws. The federal bureaucrats were not going to take orders from states to crack down on illegal voting for Democrats.
Kobach then sued to force the federal government to include proof-of-citizenship requirements on its forms for registering voters in Kansas and Arizona. State law, after all, is what defines election eligibility, not federal law. Aside from some basic laws against discrimination and allowing 18-year-olds to vote, states have broad authority to prevent illegal voting. The federal government should include additional requirements of states on voter registration forms.
Arizona had previously attempted to require voters to provide proof of citizenship for voter registration, but the Supreme Court struck down that requirement. This time, however, Arizona and Kansas did what the Supreme Court invited them to do: add the requirements on the forms that people use to register.
The 28-page decision fully upheld the proof-of-citizenship requirements. Kobach v. United States Election Assistance Commission, 2014 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 35696 (D. Kan. Mar. 19, 2014). It ruled that the "Congress has not preempted state laws requiring proof of citizenship through the National Voter Registration Act," and thus states have the power to require proof because the "Constitution gives each state exclusive authority to determine the qualifications of voters for state and federal elections."
This splendid decision by federal Judge Eric F. Melgren explained that "the Arizona and Kansas legislatures have decided that a mere oath is not sufficient to effectuate their citizenship requirements and that concrete proof of citizenship is required to register to vote. Because the Constitution gives the states exclusive authority to set voter qualifications under the Qualifications Clause, and because no clear congressional enactment attempts to preempt this authority, the Court finds that the states' determination that a mere oath is not sufficient is all the states are required to establish."
Judge Melgren then ordered the federal Election Assistance Commission "to add the language requested by Arizona and Kansas to the state-specific instructions on the federal mail voter registration form, effective immediately."
Upon reviewing this decision, Kris Kobach declared, "This is a really big victory."