On the last day of 2013 a federal judge in Brooklyn, who is himself the son of immigrants, ruled in favor of the sovereign power of the United States to search the possessions of those entering our country, without a warrant or even probable cause of wrongdoing. Abidor v. Napolitano, 2013 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 181891 (E.D.N.Y. Dec. 31, 2013). This surprisingly good decision was rendered by Senior Judge Edward Korman, who was appointed to the bench more than 28 years ago by President Ronald Reagan.
Judge Korman upheld the unfettered authority of customs agents to search laptop computers, smart phones, and other electronics brought by people entering the United States. Ordinarily a warrant or some evidence of wrongdoing would be required before government could search someone's laptop within the United States. But the "border search doctrine" has long allowed searches of the possessions of people entering this country, and the federal court rejected a challenge by the ACLU against it. The Supreme Court has held, "time and time again," that "searches made at the border, pursuant to the longstanding right of the sovereign to protect itself by stopping and examining persons and property crossing into this country, are reasonable simply by virtue of the fact that they occur at the border." United States v. Flores-Montano, 541 U.S. 149, 152-53 (2004).
In affirming a customs official's search of a laptop computer containing images of terrorist rallies, which belonged to a student who carried both a French and U.S. passport with visas to Jordan and Lebanon, the court held that border searches need not be based on probable cause or reasonable suspicion. Judge Korman traced the long tradition for authorities to search what comes into this country, whether there is reasonable suspicion or not. "This longstanding recognition that searches at our borders without probable cause and without a warrant are nonetheless 'reasonable' has a history as old as the Fourth Amendment itself," the court repeated from United States v. Ramsey, 431 U.S. 606, 619 (1977). The reason is simple: "national self-protection" against unlawful possessions being brought into our Nation.
This decision is a welcome antidote to a Ninth Circuit en banc decision that diluted border search doctrine and limited the ability of agents to search what enters our Nation. That decision imposed a new requirement of "reasonable suspicion" by border agents before they could search computers being brought into this country, and the Ninth Circuit limited the "scope and manner of the search" to what is reasonable due to the suspicion. United States v. Cotterman, 709 F.3d 952, 970 (9th Cir. 2013). Three appointees of President George W. Bush dissented from that limitation imposed by the Ninth Circuit on border agents.
Unlike the Ninth Circuit, the federal court in Brooklyn embraced a strong view of the border search doctrine that enables border agents to inspect what enters our Nation regardless of whether there is reasonable suspicion.
It was good to finish 2013 on a high note.