A bright spot among Supreme Court rulings in recent years has been the strengthening of private property rights. An 8-1 ruling by the high court in favor of Western landowners continues this trend by rejecting a claim by the United States to thousands of miles of trails in Western lands. Brandt Trust v. United States, 2014 U.S. LEXIS 1788 (Mar. 10, 2014).
The lands in dispute are the remnants of abandoned railroad tracks that wind through the West, testimony to the bygone Railroad Era. The construction of railroads out West was a big political issue that helped elect railroad attorney Abraham Lincoln as president in 1860. He campaigned by promising "that the Federal Government ought to render immediate and efficient aid in [the] construction" of a transcontinental railroad. Ely, Railroads and American Law 51 (2001). But then, as now, the federal government lacked the funds to accomplish its goal, and there were doubts about whether it could lawfully borrow money for the project. So instead Lincoln gave away vast amounts of land to railroad companies, resulting in growing public opposition to the handouts to a few wealthy companies.
Congress eventually reacted by narrowing these grants to rights-of-way 100 feet on each side of a central railroad line, in the General Railroad Right-of-Way Act of 1875. But now thousands of miles of abandoned railroad tracks, often with the tracks and ties removed, run through private property subsequently settled or acquired by homesteaders and others.
In 2006, the United States sued landowners in Wyoming, claiming that the government owns the abandoned railroad rights-of-way that traverse a swath of land there. The government insisted that when the railroad company removed its tracks and ties and abandoned the paths, the ownership in them reverted to the U.S. government as their original owner. Faced with this lawsuit and the reality that government almost always wins in court, every one of the landowners gave in to the government -- except one.
Melvin Brandt, the owner of 83 acres, argued that the right-of-way for the railroad was the equivalent of an easement. Under English common law dating back 500 years, when an easement is abandoned, the rights go to the owner of the property, not to the grantor of the easement. So even though the government originally owned the property and transferred it to Brandt expressly subject to the easement, Brandt argued that abandonment of that easement extinguishes it for his benefit. No, the government insisted, the rights to the paths reverted to it as the original owner.
Predictably, the district and appellate courts agreed with the government, without any dissent. But the Supreme Court reversed those decisions, and held entirely for Brandt.
The media reaction was total shock, complaining that public access to thousands of miles of bike trails are thereby jeopardized. But the government has no one to blame but itself, as its prior insistence in a 1942 case that these rights-of-way were merely easements came back to haunt it. Then, at oral argument, the government attorney was unable to explain how much land the government claims to own. Even Democratic-appointed Justice Breyer, an avid bicyclist, worried that there might be "right-of-way that goes through people's houses, you know, and all of a sudden they are going to be living in their house, and suddenly a bicycle will run through it!"
Thanks to this ruling in favor of private property, Westerners can enjoy dinners without fearing a surprise invasion of bicyclists who think that someone's dining room is on public land.