Media from around the world descended upon a small New Jersey courthouse to cover a lawsuit filed by an 18-year-old high school girl against her own parents for a weekly allowance of more than $600, private school tuition of thousands of dollars, future college costs and even attorneys' fees. Her best friend's father, a millionaire attorney who once held a powerful political office in the county, filed the lawsuit for her.Canning v. Canning (N.J. Superior Ct. 2014).
The trial court administrator said that he had never seen so much media attention at this Morris County courthouse. An army of reporters converged there to see if a girl, who left her parents rather than comply with their rules of the home, could then obtain a court order forcing the parents to pay her money. With so many anti-parent rulings by the courts, the high-schooler and the media had good reason to think that she might win. Perhaps to gain sympathy, the 18-year-old girl even wore her high school uniform to court for the hearing.
But they were in for a rude awakening, as Superior Court Judge Peter Bogaard in Morristown soundly rejected the girl's demands at the preliminary hearing, and even lectured the girl about how her parents are always going to be her parents. But the girl shook her head against the sound advice.
Other comments by the judge made it obvious that the parents were going to win this one. At one point he observed, "'What kind of parents would [they] be if they didn't try to set down some strict rules?" The judge also asked rhetorically, "Do we want to establish a precedent where parents live in fear of establishing basic rules of the house?"
The girl's case was not helped by the revelation of an expletive-laden phone message she had left for her own mother. Another tidbit that came out at trial was that she had allegedly threatened to sue a teacher for expelling her from the Homecoming dance because he decided she was too drunk.
The judge said about the girl's conduct, "Have you ever in your experience seen such gross disrespect for a parent? I don't see it in my house." In ruling for the parents at the preliminary hearing, he held that "I'm not going to step on a father for how he tries to get his child on the right tracks when she has obviously come off the tracks, to put it mildly."
Subsequently a call from her mother prompted the girl to return home. But the girl's second attorney, a specialist in family law, did not quit. She filed an emergency application for a court-appointed legal guardian even after the girl returned to her family. The lawyer alleged abuse by the parents, which the judge obviously did not believe as he quickly denied the request for a court-appointed guardian.
In the end, the girl took the witness stand to request that her lawsuit against her own parents be completely dismissed. The judge granted the request.