For the first time in 30 years, the U.S. Supreme Court considered and then upheld the practice of allowing public prayer at the start of a governmental meeting. Town of Greece v. Galloway, 134 S. Ct. 1184 (2014). This is an enormous triumph against current efforts to censor religion from the public square.
This decision reversed a ruling by the Second Circuit that had continued a trend of hostility to religion in public life by federal courts. The Supreme Court rejected the liberal view that any "endorsement" of religion (such as by a prayer at a government meeting) is automatically a violation of the First Amendment. Instead, the Court embraced a test long supported by Justice Kennedy that actual coercion by government of religious beliefs is all that the Establishment Clause prohibits.
Since 1999, the town of Greece, New York, had begun its local meetings with a prayer led voluntarily by a local congregation in the community. A federal lawsuit sought to stop this practice by invoking the Establishment Clause of the First Amendment. The town of Greece hoped that the Supreme Court would uphold its practice of prayer based on its decision three decades ago in Marsh v. Chambers, which held that Nebraska's practice of opening legislative sessions with a prayer led by a chaplain was not a violation of the Establishment Clause.
This time a narrow 5-4 majority on the High Court, led by Justice Kennedy, focused its inquiry on tradition and customs, ruling that prayer before town meetings fell within "the tradition long followed in Congress and the state legislatures." The Court refused to place restraints on the content of the prayers since the prayers did not coerce or force members of the community to align with a particular religious faith or adopt specific beliefs. This ruling thereby rejected the view that prayers among people in government meetings are somehow coercive on anyone who does not want to participate.
The dissent, led by Justice Breyer, wrote that the town of Greece should be more inclusive of other religions. The dissent argued that the town was in violation of the Establishment Clause because the prayers were directed toward the public and the town failed to incorporate a greater variety of religions.
But the opportunity to pray at these town meetings was open to members of all congregations and was not exclusive to the Christian faith. Additionally, there was no evidence that members of the community were coerced into abiding by any religious beliefs that may have been promoted by the prayers.
By upholding its 1983 decision in Marsh v. Chambers, the Court's decision puts the brakes on current attempts to censor opening prayers at local government meetings. The Court's reliance on history and tradition allows a practice that is a part of our nation's legislative framework and supportive of the rights set forth in the First Amendment of the Constitution. Town of Greece v. Galloway is a welcome victory for religious liberty and freedom of speech.