Court Monitor • Jun 29, 2014

Setback for Federal Power

Text Reader

An abuse of federal prosecutorial power, based on an international chemical weapons treaty, resulted in a woman's six-year prison sentence for merely causing a small skin burn on another woman's thumb. A purely domestic dispute that had nothing to do with war or foreign policy became a massive "federal case" illustrative of federal overreaching and the misuse of treaties. Carol Anne Bond's "crime" was to cause a minor skin burn to a romantic rival who had had an affair with (and become pregnant by) her husband. The burn could be readily treated by rinsing it with water. For that crime, Mrs. Bond was prosecuted in federal court under a law implementing an international treaty for banning chemical weapons, because she had used a chemical to cause the injury. Mrs. Bond was then sentenced to six years -- six years! -- for this "federal crime" that was simply a domestic squabble. Most cases like this would never get to the Supreme Court, but a pro bono effort resulted in two remarkable trips for this to the High Court. In the first trip, the Court confirmed that Mrs. Bond has a right to assert the Tenth Amendment to defend against actions by Congress that go beyond its constitutional power. When the Third Circuit subsequently reaffirmed the federal conviction of Mrs. Bond, the Supreme Court granted cert. a second time. The Supreme Court was already fully familiar with the facts of this case from its prior decision, but it then took another astonishing seven months to decide, even though the Justices were unanimous that the federal conviction of Mrs. Bond should be overturned. Bond v. United States, 2014 U.S. LEXIS 3988 (June 2, 2014). Why the delay? Chief Justice Roberts' opinion for the Court was sarcastic towards the prosecution of the case, and even wondered if people would soon be prosecuted in federal court for something as silly as using vinegar to kill goldfish in a dirty fish tank. He ruled on behalf of the Court that the treaty, and the federal statute implementing it, should not be interpreted to apply to Mrs. Bond's actions. Though Chief Justice Roberts' sarcasm is legendary, it may have irked Justice Alito, who is a former federal prosecutor. He wrote separately to defend the prosecution as a correct application of the statute, but then said that the statute went beyond congressional power by intruding into local law enforcement. No Justice joined Justice Alito's separate concurrence. Justices Scalia and Thomas wrote their own concurrences to advocate what many conservatives have long sought: to overrule a decision from the 1920s, Missouri v. Holland, which contains a sentence suggesting that Congress may go beyond its limited powers set forth in the Constitution, by claiming that its actions are authorized by an international treaty. That decision is considered one of the worst dozen decisions not yet overturned, because it allows Congress to grab new powers for itself simply by ratifying bad treaties. But only two out of nine Justices wanted to overturn Missouri v. Holland.