Tour guides lead visitors in many cities to the local landmarks, teaching some history along the way. But in recent years several cities enacted laws requiring tour guides to be certified in history before they can charge the public for their tours.
In 2008, reportedly in response to embarrassing falsehoods spread by tour guides about Ben Franklin, the Philadelphia City Council required tour guides to pass a history test before they could charge for guide services. Among the falsehoods that this new licensing requirement would supposedly stop was a statement by a tour guide that George Washington once had lunch with Abraham Lincoln at the Powell House in the city.
Tours of Independence Hall, where the Declaration of Independence and the U.S. Constitution were composed and signed, are conducted by the National Park Service of the federal government. Those tour guides say only what they are allowed to say, because Independence Hall is part of the National Park Service, just as Yellowstone Park in Wyoming is. But outside of Independence Hall and other National Parks, it was anything goes until cities began requiring tour guide licenses. The law passed in Philadelphia requires that a tour guide attain a score of at least 65% on a test containing 150 questions about historical sites in the city.
New Orleans passed a similar law to require licensing of tour guides, despite the claim that visitors to New Orleans often want to be entertained rather than schooled. The licensing requirement in New Orleans tested applicants on their knowledge of historical, cultural and sociological developments, and on landmarks in the city. The law also required that the aspiring tour guides must not have been convicted of a felony in the last five years, and must pass a drug test. The fee was $50 with the initial application, and then $20 for renewal every two years.
The Institute for Justice sued, based on the First Amendment, to overturn these requirements. "Government can't make sure you understand the Constitution before it has to abide by it," one of its attorneys, Robert McNamara, observed.
After losing in the district court, the Institute for Justice appealed to the Fifth Circuit, and was supported in its challenge by an amicus brief filed by Cato, the leading libertarian think tank. The three-judge panel included two Democrat-appointed judges and Judge Edith Jones, an outstanding conservative judge.
The court unanimously upheld the licensing requirement, because "the New Orleans law in its requirements for a license has no effect whatsoever on the content of what tour guides say. Those who get the license can speak as they please." Kagan v. City of New Orleans, 753 F.3d 560 (5th Cir. 2014). The Institute for Justice then sought review by the U.S. Supreme Court, and Cato filed an amicus brief in support. But the U.S. Supreme Court refused to hear the appeal, and the licensing requirement remains in effect in New Orleans and many other cities.