"Hackney carriage" is the predecessor in the horse-and-buggy era to the taxicab, and this term continues to be used in many municipal codes in Massachusetts. Hackney carriages, or taxicabs today, are fully regulated in big cities such as Boston. A taxi medallion is required before a car can be used as a taxi, and eventually these medallions became so valuable that they exceeded a market value of $1 million per medallion in New York City.
But last year the value of taxicab medallions began to plummet due to competition from a new source: cell phones and start-up companies using drivers in their own private cars. Travelers and commuters in big cities started using "apps" on their cell phones to connect with drivers who would then take them to their destination more cheaply than a taxi would. One company named "Uber" offers this service, and it has become so popular that its own market value is worth an estimated tens of billions of dollars and, by some estimates, exceeds even the market value of Delta Airlines.
As the popularity of Uber has risen, taxi medallions have declined in their value. For example, roughly a year ago in Boston the taxi medallions were selling at $700,000 apiece. But six months later, a Boston taxi medallion sold for only $561,000, and two months after that, there were no buyers for Boston taxi medallions at a price of only $425,000.
Taxicab owners sued Boston and the State of Massachusetts for how their regulatory scheme puts taxis at a disadvantage. Taxicab owners pointed out that they must comply with a litany of regulations issued by the Police Commissioner, while Uber and other ride-sharing services do not.
Uber drivers, who are sometimes former taxicab drivers, are transporting customers in their own private cars without the expensive taxi medallions. The taxicab owners argued in court that the failure of Boston to regulate Uber and similar cell phone-based car services has caused the value of their taxi medallions to decline.
The federal district court rejected the taxicab owners' requested relief. Boston Taxi Owners Ass'n v. City of Boston, 2015 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 14564 (D. Mass. Feb. 5, 2015). The court held that mere inaction by government does not establish an unconstitutional "taking" of anyone's property. Instead, "the government must act affirmatively to warrant the application of the Takings Clause," the court ruled. The Court also said that the market value of something (taxi medallions) would not be protected by the Takings Clause anyway. Likewise, the Equal Protection Clause does not help the taxicab owners, because the court found free-market justification in Boston's reluctance to regulate Uber and other new transportation providers.
But ultimately the court did express sympathy for the taxicab owners' predicament, albeit with an unfortunate preference for more regulation rather than less. The court promised "to re-examine . . . the City's assertion that it is actively and seriously considering the promulgation of . . . regulations [against Uber and similar cell phone-based car services] that will be fair to the taxi industry and ensure public safety."