Two pastors from a small town in Alabama won a stunning, unanimous victory before the Alabama Supreme Court against the sale of alcohol in their tiny community. Bynum v. City of Oneonta, 2015 Ala. LEXIS 31 (Feb. 27, 2015). Aided by a conservative attorney, the pastors successfully argued that an Alabama statute was unconstitutional in allowing small towns to hold referenda to permit the sale of alcohol.
More than 80 years after the repeal of Prohibition, there continue to be many "dry" counties in the United States that prohibit the sale of alcohol. About half of the counties in Arkansas, for example, continue to prohibit the sale of alcohol.
Opposition to alcohol sales is not merely a vestige of a bygone era. A few months ago, in November 2014, a statewide referendum to eliminate dry counties in Arkansas lost by landslide margin of 57-43%. Millions of Americans oppose the sale of alcohol, or support strict restrictions on its sale.
For example, there are entire cities in Alaska which went dry in the 1960s, and some cities in Mississippi went dry the 1980s, a half-century after the end of Prohibition. Dozens of towns in New Jersey and New York continue to be completely or partially dry today. Even today in New York City, at least one popular bar limits the late night sale of alcohol to patrons older than 25 years, which is stricter than what the law requires. Nationwide, ten states allow entire counties to prohibit alcohol sales, and another fifteen states allow "partially dry" or "moist" regions to sharply restrict alcohol sales.
In the fall of 2012, the residents of Blount County, Alabama voted against allowing alcohol sales. But the election returns showed that a majority of voters in its small town of Oneonta, having a population of only 6,600, supported the sale of alcohol. Subsequently, the town sought to hold its own referendum on the issue, and then the litigation began.
An Alabama law allowed individual towns to hold referenda on whether to allow the sale of alcohol, but the statute excluded Blount County and two other counties from this process. A resident cited the exclusion in challenging the expenditure of town funds to hold an alcohol referendum, and two pastors intervened in the lawsuit to oppose the referendum. The trial court ruled against them, and the pastors then appealed to the Alabama Supreme Court, which is led by Chief Justice Roy Moore.
The pastors were right, the High Court held, and the trial court had erred in rewriting the statute to allow the referendum to move forward in Blount County. The Court found that because the statute did not contain a severability clause, the trial court should not have severed the exception for Blount County from the remainder of the statute. Chief Justice Roy Moore concurred the outcome, but wrote separately to express his view that the Court should have blocked the referendum by invalidating the statute under the Alabama Constitution, rather than analyzing it under the U.S. Constitution.