Court Monitor • Jun 21, 2015

Border Patrol Agent Wins One

Text Reader

A teenager was shot and killed while entirely on Mexican soil, by a federal border patrol agent who was on the American side. The teenager's family then sued, alleging that the boy was playing a harmless game with friends near the border when he was gunned down by the federal officer. American investigators rejected that account, instead concluding that the agent was trying to arrest illegal aliens who had crossed into the United States when the agent was attacked by rocks thrown at him. A federal district court in El Paso, Texas, dismissed the family's lawsuit based on lack of jurisdiction. Congress does not allow federal courts to award judgments against the United States except where Congress has specifically authorized it. No such law exists for this injury suffered outside the United States. The court rejected the argument that this injury occurred in the United States because the officer fired his gun here. The decision was appealed, and affirmed by a panel on the Fifth Circuit. It held that a Mexican who is killed on Mexican soil has no Fourth Amendment rights under the Constitution. But the panel also ruled that "a noncitizen injured outside the United States as a result of arbitrary official conduct by a law enforcement officer located in the United States may invoke the protections provided by the Fifth Amendment," which prohibits the taking of a life without due process. Hernandez v. United States, 757 F.3d 249, 272 (5th Cir. 2014). The Fourth Amendment is limited to this country because, by its own terms, it applies only to "the people." The Fifth Amendment, in contrast, applies to "any person." The Fifth Circuit next convened en banc so that all 15 active judges could weigh in on this important issue, but it also affirmed the dismissal of this lawsuit. Hernandez v. United States, 2015 U.S. App. LEXIS 6827 (5th Cir. Apr. 24, 2015). Five of its most conservative judges, led by Edith Jones, concurred by flatly rejecting the notion that there could ever be a valid Fifth Amendment claim against the federal government for a killing in Mexico. Interestingly, however, other conservatives on the Fifth Circuit (including Judge Jennifer Elrod, who is a potential future Republican nominee for the Supreme Court), declined to join this categorical exclusion of the Fifth Amendment. Judge Jones added a check and balance on overreach by federal agents. A victim could sue in state court by alleging that the federal agent overstepped his authority, based on 28 U.S.C. § 2679(d)(3). The federal government would surely transfer such a lawsuit to federal court, but the statute provides that if "the district court determines that the employee was not acting within the scope of his office or employment, the action or proceeding shall be remanded to the State court" for resolution in state court. The FBI, the United States Attorney's Office, the Department of Homeland Security's Office of the Inspector General, and the Justice Department's Civil Rights Division, which are not known to be supportive of strong border security, investigated this incident and decided not to extradite the border patrol agent to Mexico or prosecute him here.